Crime Solvers Central
CSC
246 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.
Crime Solvers Central Cases Blog
BLOG HOME
  • 0 Into the Winter Shadows: The Unresolved Disappearance of Michael Dillard

    0.00 of 0 votes

    A Promising Life InterruptedMichael Allen Dillard, a 15-year-old from Calvin, West Virginia, vanished on January 12, 2018. Known for his vibrant personality and close-knit family ties, Michael's sudden disappearance has left a void in the hearts of those who knew him. Despite extensive search efforts and investigations, his whereabouts remain unknown.A Struggle with Mental HealthMichael faced significant mental health challenges, including severe depression. He spent nearly a year in a specialized treatment center for adolescents dealing with similar issues, returning home on December 19, 2017. His family noted improvements in his condition, with Michael expressing optimism about his future.The Day He DisappearedOn the day of his disappearance, Michael visited his sister Brittany with his mother. Brittany observed that Michael seemed unusually quiet and withdrawn, a stark contrast to his upbeat demeanor just days earlier. Upon returning home, while helping his mother carry wood pellets, Michael abruptly ran into the wooded area behind their house and was never seen again.Immediate Search EffortsMichael's family quickly reported his disappearance, prompting a massive search operation involving helicopters, dive teams, bloodhounds, and volunteers. The search was hampered by severe weather conditions, including freezing temperatures and snow, which may have obscured potential clues.Discovery of His JacketApproximately a week and a half later, Michael's orange jacket was found about 300 yards from his home. The jacket was clean and undamaged, suggesting it had been removed intentionally. This discovery raised questions about whether Michael had succumbed to hypothermia, a condition that can cause individuals to undress due to a false sensation of warmth.Unconfirmed Sightings and TheoriesA neighbor reported seeing Michael walking along Tioga Road in Craigsville shortly after his disappearance, but this sighting remains unverified. Some speculate that Michael may have attempted to hitch a ride, possibly ending up in North Carolina. Others believe he may have sought shelter in an abandoned vehicle or structure, succumbing to the elements.Ongoing Investigation and HopeDespite the passage of time, Michael's case remains open. Authorities continue to investigate leads, and his family holds onto hope for answers. A $3,000 reward is offered for information leading to his discovery. Michael is described as a white male with brown hair and hazel eyes, standing 5'5" tall and weighing 133 pounds at the time of his disappearance.How You Can Help If you have any information regarding Michael Dillard's disappearance, please contact the West Virginia State Police at 872-0800 or the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children at 1-800-THE-LOST . Your assistance could provide crucial insights into this enduring mystery.

  • 0 Vanished in the Pines: The Unsolved Disappearance of Konrad Reichenberger in Rural California

    0.00 of 0 votes

    A Quiet Life in the California PinesKonrad Charles Reichenberger, known to friends as "Kurt," was a 44-year-old man living a quiet life in the California Pines Hill area near Alturas, California. Standing at 6'2" and weighing 200 pounds, Konrad was known for his brown hair, hazel eyes, and distinctive tattoos, including a card deck and a Ford logo on his arms . He often kept his hair very short or nearly shaved and typically had facial hair. Konrad was deeply attached to his dogs, a fact that would later become a poignant detail in his disappearance.The Day He DisappearedOn January 12 or 13, 2018, Konrad was last seen at his cabin home in the California Pines Hill area. The exact date varies among reports, but what is consistent is that he vanished without a trace during a time when several feet of snow blanketed the region . His friend reported him missing on January 16 after several days of no contact .An Ongoing MysteryDespite investigations by the Modoc County Sheriff's Department and listings in national databases like NamUs , Konrad's case remains unsolved. The rural and rugged terrain of Modoc County, known for its wilderness and sparse population, poses significant challenges for search efforts. Additionally, the area has been noted for illegal activities such as unauthorized logging and clandestine drug operations, which could complicate the circumstances surrounding his disappearance .Community and Personal ImpactFriends and family continue to search for answers. Heather Hobson Lewis, a friend of Konrad's, has written about his disappearance, emphasizing that he would never have left his beloved dogs behind willingly . The lack of closure has left a lasting impact on those who knew him, as they grapple with the uncertainty and hope for any information that could lead to understanding what happened.Call for InformationAuthorities urge anyone with information about Konrad Reichenberger's disappearance to contact the Modoc County Sheriff's Department at 233-4416. Even the smallest detail could be crucial in shedding light on this enduring mystery.Conclusion The disappearance of Konrad Reichenberger is a stark reminder of how quickly and inexplicably someone can vanish, especially in remote areas. As time passes, the hope remains that answers will emerge, bringing closure to his loved ones and justice to his case.

  • 0 The Vanishing of David Stillwell: A Missouri Mystery That Endures

    0.00 of 0 votes

    A Quiet Disappearance in Sugar CreekDavid G. Stillwell, a 68-year-old resident of Independence, Missouri, was last seen on January 9, 2018. His disappearance has remained unsolved, leaving few clues about his whereabouts. Stillwell, who had gray hair and brown eyes, was about 5'8" to 6'0" tall and weighed between 180 and 220 pounds. He also had a distinguishing scar on his chest from previous heart surgery. Physical Description and IdentifiersDavid Stillwell was a Caucasian male with gray or partially gray hair and brown eyes. His height ranged between 5'8" and 6'0", and he weighed between 180 and 220 pounds. A notable distinguishing feature was a scar on his chest from previous heart surgery. Investigative Efforts and ChallengesThe Sugar Creek Police Department has been the primary agency investigating Stillwell's disappearance. Despite their efforts, the case has yielded little information, and no significant leads have emerged. The lack of evidence has made it challenging to determine the circumstances surrounding his disappearance. Community Involvement and Public AwarenessThe case has been listed in national databases such as the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System and featured on platforms like the Charley Project and Uncovered. These listings aim to raise public awareness and encourage anyone with information to come forward. Family's Ongoing Search for AnswersDetails about Stillwell's family and their efforts to locate him are scarce. However, the prolonged absence and lack of closure undoubtedly weigh heavily on his loved ones. The uncertainty surrounding his fate continues to be a source of distress.The Broader Context of Missing Persons CasesStillwell's case is one among many unsolved missing persons cases in Missouri. The challenges faced in such investigations highlight the importance of public cooperation and the need for continued attention to these cases.Conclusion David Stillwell's disappearance remains a mystery. Despite the passage of time, the hope for answers persists. Anyone with information is urged to contact the Sugar Creek Police Department at 816-252-7058.

  • 0 Vanished in the Permian Basin: The Unsolved Disappearance of Caitlin Denison

    0.00 of 0 votes

    A Young Woman’s Journey into the UnknownCaitlin Marie Denison, a 19-year-old from Reno, Nevada, vanished under mysterious circumstances in January 2018. Described as a vibrant and petite young woman, Caitlin stood 5'5" tall, weighed approximately 120 pounds, and had blonde hair and blue eyes. She was known for her distinctive tattoos, including a Libra scale on her right forearm and an alien head with the letter "M" on one of her left fingers. Caitlin also had multiple piercings and scars on her arms and legs from self-inflicted cuts .A Fateful DecisionIn 2017, Caitlin met a man from Midland, Texas, while in Reno. Six months later, on January 9, 2018, she flew with him to Midland. Before leaving, she expressed concerns to her sister, stating, "this guy makes me scared for my life." Despite these fears, she proceeded with the trip, not disclosing the man's name or appearance to her family .The Last Known MovementsUpon arriving in Midland, Caitlin contacted her family on January 10, 2018, from a Walmart store on North Midland Drive. She conveyed fear for her safety during this call. It is believed that she and the man visited a Domino's Pizza on Linda Avenue in Odessa and then went to Rick's Cabaret, possibly seeking employment. Caitlin may have spent the night with the man in his RV, which was reportedly parked in West Odessa before being moved to a location south of IH-20/Loop 250 in Midland. She has not been seen or heard from since .The Investigation and Renewed InterestThe man Caitlin traveled with has been identified and was known to work as a truck driver in the Permian Basin oil industry. He was questioned by police in Nevada, but authorities have not disclosed whether he is a suspect. In October 2024, the Texas Department of Public Safety and Texas Rangers renewed interest in the case, citing new information. Investigators believe the public may hold vital information to solve the case .Search Efforts and Public AppealsIn January 2025, the Texas Rangers searched a vacant lot at an RV park located at the intersection of South County Road 1223 1/2 and West County Road 120 in Midland County, following up on leads related to Caitlin's disappearance. Authorities have released a photo of the Ford F-250 pickup truck that Caitlin was last seen in, hoping someone may recognize it or provide additional leads .How the Public Can HelpThe Texas DPS and Crime Stoppers are urging anyone with information about Caitlin's disappearance to come forward. Anonymous tips can be submitted online through the Texas Rangers' Cold Case website or by calling the Texas Rangers at 1-800-346-3243. Crime Stoppers is offering a cash reward of up to $3,000 for information leading to the arrest of the person or persons responsible for this crime. To be eligible for the reward, tipsters must call the Crime Stoppers hotline at 1-800-252-TIPS .Conclusion Caitlin Denison's disappearance remains an unsolved mystery that continues to haunt her family and the community. Despite renewed efforts and public appeals, her whereabouts are still unknown. Authorities remain hopeful that someone holds the key to unlocking the truth behind Caitlin's disappearance and urge anyone with information to come forward.

  • 0 Into the Shadows: The Disappearance of Travis Church in Yulee, Florida

    0.00 of 0 votes

    A Quiet Community ShakenYulee, Florida, a small town nestled in Nassau County, is known for its close-knit community and tranquil surroundings. However, on January 9, 2018, the peace was disrupted when 24-year-old Travis Daniel Church vanished under mysterious circumstances, leaving the community and his family searching for answers.The Day Travis DisappearedOn that fateful day, Travis was involved in a foot pursuit with a Florida Highway Patrol trooper. The chase led him into the dense woods on Owens Farm Road in Yulee. Despite efforts to locate him, Travis was never seen or heard from again. His disappearance was officially reported nine days later, on January 18, 2018. A Profile of Travis ChurchTravis Daniel Church was born on July 23, 1993. At the time of his disappearance, he was 24 years old, standing 5 feet 11 inches tall and weighing approximately 152 pounds. He had brown hair and green eyes. Described as a Caucasian male, Travis's sudden disappearance left a void in the lives of those who knew him. The Search EffortsFollowing his disappearance, the Nassau County Sheriff's Office initiated an investigation. Despite search efforts in the area where he was last seen, no substantial leads emerged. The dense woods and challenging terrain made the search difficult. Over time, the lack of new information caused the case to grow cold. Community Response and Ongoing EffortsThe community of Yulee and organizations dedicated to solving cold cases have continued to keep Travis's case in the public eye. Websites like Uncovered have featured his story, encouraging individuals to contribute any information that might aid in solving the case. The Impact on Loved OnesTravis's disappearance has had a profound impact on his family and friends. The uncertainty surrounding his fate has been a source of ongoing pain and confusion. Each passing year without answers adds to the anguish experienced by those who cared for him.Conclusion: A Call for InformationAs of now, Travis Daniel Church remains missing, and his case is unsolved. Authorities urge anyone with information to come forward. Tips can be submitted to the Nassau County Sheriff's Office at 904-548-4085. Even the smallest piece of information could be crucial in uncovering the truth behind Travis's disappearance. If you have any information about the case, please contact the Nassau County Sheriff's Office at 904-548-4085.

  • 0 Vanished Without a Trace: The Unsolved Disappearance of Kyle Jay Ellis

    0.00 of 0 votes

    A Mysterious Disappearance in the Heart of WyomingOn the evening of January 8, 2018, 29-year-old Kyle Jay Ellis was dropped off at a gas station in Greybull, Wyoming, by a woman who had given him a ride from Bear Lodge in the Bighorn Mountains. She also gave him $20 for a meal. This was the last confirmed sighting of Kyle. He has not been seen or heard from since. A Troubled Past and a Search for MeaningKyle's life before his disappearance was marked by struggles with mental health and substance abuse. Once an honor student and multi-sport athlete, he attended the University of Las Vegas, where he began to exhibit signs of mental illness, including excessive partying and self-medication. He eventually dropped out, leading to a cycle of drug and alcohol abuse, arrests, and a stint in rehab in Rock Springs, Wyoming. Though unofficially diagnosed with bipolar disorder, his mother believes he may have suffered from borderline personality disorder or schizophrenia. Kyle was known to resist medication and treatment. The Final Days Before DisappearanceOn the day he vanished, Kyle had been staying at Bear Lodge in the Bighorn Mountains. Concerned for his safety after he was seen sitting outside in the cold, the lodge's owner called the police. Kyle spoke to his father on the phone, who offered to pick him up, but Kyle declined. Instead, he accepted a ride from a woman who dropped him off at a gas station in Greybull and gave him $20. There is no surveillance footage from the gas station or surrounding areas to track his movements after that point. A Pattern of WanderingKyle was known for embarking on religious journeys, sometimes disappearing for up to two weeks at a time. He had traveled as far as the West Coast and Texas on these trips. However, during previous journeys, he always maintained contact with his family through Facebook Messenger. He typically did not carry electronics or identification and often dressed inappropriately for the weather, usually wearing a white t-shirt. A Mother's Unyielding HopeDespite the years that have passed, Kyle's mother, Heather Vanderhoef, remains hopeful that her son will return. She finds solace in stories of missing persons being found after many years. Kyle had expressed a desire to visit the San Juan Islands off the Washington Coast, a place the family frequented for vacations. A friend periodically searches for him among the homeless population there but has not found any trace of him. The Ongoing InvestigationThe Sheridan County Sheriff's Office continues to investigate Kyle's disappearance. As of now, there have been no credible tips, sightings, or evidence leading to his whereabouts. In March 2025, human skeletal remains were discovered in Washakie County, Wyoming. Authorities are working to identify the remains, but it is unclear if they are connected to Kyle's case. Physical Description and Identifying FeaturesAt the time of his disappearance, Kyle was 6 feet tall and weighed approximately 190 pounds. He had brown hair, hazel eyes, and wore glasses. He was known to wear a black beanie year-round. Kyle has several distinctive tattoos: a sleeve on his left forearm, pinup girls on both shoulders, and the phrase "Sex, Drugs, Rock N Roll" on his abdomen.A Call for InformationAnyone with information about Kyle Jay Ellis is urged to contact the Sheridan County Sheriff's Office at 672-3455 or the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System toll-free hotline at 872-5176.Conclusion The disappearance of Kyle Jay Ellis remains a haunting mystery. Despite extensive searches and ongoing investigations, his whereabouts are still unknown. His family continues to hold out hope for his return, clinging to the possibility that he may one day come back to them. Until then, they, along with law enforcement, continue to seek answers in the hope of bringing closure to this enduring case.

  • 0 Vanished Without a Trace: The Unsettling Disappearance of Christa Marie Coleman in Everett

    0.00 of 0 votes

    A Quiet Life InterruptedOn April 1, 2025, Christa Marie Coleman, a 39-year-old resident of Everett, Washington, was reported missing by the staff of the adult family home where she resided. Christa, standing at 5 feet tall and weighing approximately 140 pounds, has black hair and hazel eyes. At the time of her disappearance, she was last seen wearing a long black jacket over a gray hoodie, black pants, and carrying a large black purse .The Initial Search EffortsThe Everett Police Department promptly initiated an investigation into Christa's disappearance. Her case was entered into the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System under case number MP144604 . Despite these efforts, there have been no significant leads or developments reported in the months following her disappearance.Community Response and AwarenessThe local community has been deeply affected by Christa's disappearance. Websleuths, an online community dedicated to crime and missing persons cases, has an active thread discussing her case, where members share information and theories in hopes of uncovering new leads . Additionally, organizations like Victim Support Services have been instrumental in raising awareness about missing persons in Washington State, hosting events and providing resources to families and communities affected by such cases .The Broader Context of Missing Persons in WashingtonChrista's case is one among many in Washington State, where at any given time, approximately 2,000 people are reported missing . The state ranks within the top ten in the nation for missing persons cases, highlighting a broader issue that affects numerous families and communities. Efforts by law enforcement and advocacy groups continue to focus on improving reporting systems, increasing public awareness, and providing support to those impacted.Continuing the Search for Answers As of July 2025, Christa Marie Coleman remains missing, with no new information available regarding her whereabouts. The Everett Police Department continues to seek any information that could assist in locating her. Individuals with information are encouraged to contact the Everett Police Department at 425-257-8400. The hope remains that increased awareness and community involvement will lead to answers and bring Christa home.

  • 0 Vanished Without a Trace: The Enigmatic Disappearance of Daryl Cauthen

    0.00 of 0 votes

    A Quiet Life in SmyrnaDaryl Anthony Cauthen was a 39-year-old man residing in Smyrna, Georgia. Standing at an imposing 6'5" and weighing between 200 and 240 pounds, Daryl was a noticeable presence in his community. Described as a white male with blond or strawberry-colored hair and blue eyes, he led a life that, to most observers, seemed ordinary and unremarkable.Uncharacteristic Behavior EmergesIn the days leading up to his disappearance on January 6, 2018, Daryl exhibited behavior that was both unusual and alarming to those who knew him. He began giving away or selling all of his possessions, a move that puzzled friends and family alike. Additionally, he left several notes for his family members, the contents of which have not been publicly disclosed. These actions suggested a man preparing for a significant change or departure, though the reasons remained unclear.The Day He DisappearedJanuary 6, 2018, marked the last confirmed sighting of Daryl in Smyrna. There were no reports of distress or incidents that day, but his sudden absence raised immediate concerns. The combination of his recent behavior and abrupt disappearance prompted his family to report him missing, initiating an investigation by the Smyrna Police Department.A Clue Surfaces in San FranciscoNearly a month after Daryl vanished, a significant development occurred. On February 4, 2018, his vehicle was discovered abandoned in the parking lot of the YMCA located at 63 Lincoln Boulevard in San Francisco, California. This location is over 2,400 miles from Smyrna, adding a perplexing layer to the case. The discovery of his truck so far from home suggested that Daryl had traveled across the country, but the reasons for this journey and his activities during that time remain unknown.Investigative Efforts and ChallengesThe Smyrna Police Department, with Detective Kristee Pettis leading the case, has been the primary agency investigating Daryl's disappearance. Despite their efforts, including collaboration with other law enforcement agencies and public appeals for information, leads have been scarce. The case has been entered into the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System under case number MP41987, ensuring that the details are accessible to a broader network of investigators and the public.Community Response and Ongoing HopeDaryl's disappearance has left a void in his community and among his loved ones. The lack of answers has been a source of ongoing anguish. Online platforms and forums have been used to share information and theories, but no substantial leads have emerged. The community continues to hope for a breakthrough that will shed light on what happened to Daryl and provide closure to those affected by his absence.Conclusion The case of Daryl Cauthen remains one of the many unresolved missing person cases that perplex investigators and haunt families. His sudden disappearance, preceded by uncharacteristic behavior and culminating in the discovery of his vehicle across the country, presents a series of unanswered questions. As time passes, the hope for answers endures, with the community and law enforcement remaining vigilant in their search for the truth behind Daryl's mysterious vanishing.

  • 0 The Silent Vanishing of Sergio Portillo: Unraveling a Laredo Mystery

    0.00 of 0 votes

    A Quiet Disappearance in the Gateway CityOn April 4, 2025, Sergio Ramirez Portillo, a 75-year-old resident of Laredo, Texas, was last seen. His sudden disappearance has since become a perplexing case that has left his family and the community searching for answers. Despite being added to the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System as case #MP145439, details surrounding his vanishing remain scarce .The Man Behind the NameSergio Portillo was described as a Hispanic male, standing 5 feet 6 inches tall and weighing approximately 150 pounds. He had gray or partially gray hair and black eyes. At the time of his disappearance, he was 75 years old. Friends and neighbors recall him as a quiet individual who kept to himself, making his sudden absence all the more concerning.The Investigation BeginsFollowing his disappearance, the Laredo Police Department initiated an investigation. Detective Saul Aguirre was assigned to the case, and it was officially reported on May 30, 2025, under case number 2025-00086253 . Despite efforts to locate Portillo, leads have been minimal, and the case remains open.Community Efforts and ChallengesThe community has rallied to support the search for Portillo. Flyers have been distributed, and social media campaigns have been launched to raise awareness. However, the lack of concrete information has made the search challenging. Some residents have expressed frustration over the limited updates from authorities, while others continue to hold out hope for his safe return.The Broader Context of Missing Persons in LaredoPortillo's case is not isolated. Laredo has seen several missing persons cases over the years, with varying degrees of resolution. The city's proximity to the U.S.-Mexico border adds complexity to such investigations, as individuals may cross borders, intentionally or otherwise, complicating jurisdiction and search efforts.The Importance of Public AwarenessRaising public awareness is crucial in missing persons cases. Community involvement can lead to tips and information that might otherwise go unnoticed. In Portillo's case, any detail, no matter how minor it may seem, could prove pivotal in uncovering his whereabouts.A Call to ActionAuthorities urge anyone with information about Sergio Portillo's disappearance to come forward. Detective Saul Aguirre can be reached at the Laredo Police Department by calling 956-795-2904. Even the smallest piece of information could be the key to solving this case and bringing closure to those affected.Conclusion The disappearance of Sergio Portillo remains a somber reminder of the challenges faced in missing persons cases. As time passes, the urgency to find answers grows. The community's continued vigilance and cooperation with law enforcement are essential in the ongoing search for Portillo.

  • 0 Into the Wilderness: The Unsolved Disappearance of Army Veteran Thomas “TJ” Nigro

    0.00 of 0 votes

    A Veteran's Vanishing: The Mysterious Case of Thomas “TJ” NigroOn January 5, 2018, Thomas Joseph “TJ” Nigro, a 31-year-old U.S. Army veteran, disappeared under puzzling circumstances. A former Army Ranger from Columbus, Georgia, Nigro was last seen being dropped off near the intersection of Bevis Road and GBI Road in Franklin, Georgia—an area bordering the expansive West Point Wildlife Management Area. Despite his military training and survival skills, Nigro has not been seen or heard from since that day.A Hitchhiker's Journey: The Last Known SightingA woman reported picking up Nigro while he was hitchhiking in Columbus and driving him to Franklin. He told her he planned to meet a friend for a week-long camping trip. She noted that he had camping gear, including a heavy-duty black bag and a rolled-up dark green sleeping bag. She also mentioned that he had a cell phone with him, suggesting he might have had a secondary phone, as his primary phone was left at home.Unsettling Discoveries: Personal Belongings Left BehindUpon investigating Nigro's residence, authorities found several personal items left behind: his passport, car keys, wallet, sunglasses, and a photograph of his daughter. These belongings, typically essential for travel or camping, were conspicuously absent from his gear. The presence of these items at his home raises questions about his intentions and the circumstances leading to his disappearance. Physical Challenges: Injuries and LimitationsNigro had sustained head and back injuries during his military service, including a traumatic brain injury from a helicopter crash. These injuries limited his mobility, making it difficult for him to walk long distances. Despite his survival training, his physical limitations would have posed significant challenges in the rugged terrain of the West Point Wildlife Management Area. The Search Efforts: A Community's ResponseFollowing his disappearance, search efforts were concentrated around the area where he was last seen. Despite extensive searches, no trace of Nigro was found. The vastness of the West Point Wildlife Management Area, covering nearly 9,000 acres, complicated search efforts. The challenging terrain and dense foliage made it difficult for search teams to conduct thorough sweeps. Family and Friends: Holding onto HopeNigro's family and friends have remained steadfast in their efforts to find him. They have utilized social media platforms to raise awareness and gather information. Despite the passage of time, they continue to hope for answers and closure. The emotional toll of his disappearance has been profound, affecting all who knew him. Official Investigation: An Ongoing CaseThe Columbus Police Department continues to investigate Nigro's disappearance. They have urged anyone with information to come forward, emphasizing that even the smallest detail could be crucial. The case remains open, with authorities exploring all possible leads. Theories and Speculations: Unanswered QuestionsSeveral theories have emerged regarding Nigro's disappearance. Some speculate that he may have encountered foul play, while others believe he may have become lost or incapacitated due to his injuries. The lack of concrete evidence has fueled various speculations, but none have provided definitive answers. The Passage of Time: A Lingering MysteryAs years have passed since Nigro's disappearance, the mystery remains unsolved. The lack of new information has been frustrating for both investigators and his loved ones. Despite the challenges, the determination to find answers persists. The case serves as a poignant reminder of the many missing persons whose stories remain unresolved. Conclusion: A Call for Information The disappearance of Thomas “TJ” Nigro continues to baffle investigators and haunt his family and friends. Anyone with information is urged to contact the Columbus Police Department at 706-653-3205. Even the smallest detail could be the key to unraveling this enduring mystery.