The Redhead in the Refrigerator: The Unsolved Murder of Espy Pilgrim and the Shadow of a Serial Killer ​

Discovery in Gray, Kentucky

On April 1, 1985, a grim discovery was made near the entrance to Gray, Kentucky. Two men searching for spare parts stumbled upon a discarded white Admiral refrigerator in a rural dumpsite off U.S. Route 25E. Inside lay the body of a young woman, unclothed except for two pairs of socks and adorned with two necklaces—one featuring a heart pendant and the other a gold-colored eagle. The refrigerator bore a sticker reading "Super Woman," a haunting detail that would linger in the minds of investigators and the public alike.

The Jane Doe Investigation

The victim was estimated to be between 24 and 35 years old, standing approximately 4 feet 9 inches to 4 feet 11 inches tall. She had long red hair, light brown eyes, and several distinguishing features, including a yellow-stained upper incisor, multiple moles, and a scar on her abdomen indicative of childbirth. An autopsy revealed that she had died from asphyxiation, though there were no signs of strangulation. Witnesses reported seeing a woman matching her description at a truck stop in Corbin, Kentucky, the day before her body was found, attempting to hitch a ride to North Carolina.

A Community Mourns

The case garnered significant attention in the quiet town of Gray. Approximately 500 people attended the Jane Doe's funeral, which was televised, reflecting the community's deep sense of loss and the mystery surrounding her identity. Despite extensive efforts, the victim remained unidentified for over three decades, known only as the "Redhead in the Refrigerator."

Breakthrough Through DNA

In 2018, a significant breakthrough occurred when a relative from North Carolina, prompted by a social media post about the case, contacted authorities. DNA samples were collected from the woman's children, leading to a positive identification: the victim was Espy Regina Black-Pilgrim from Spindale, North Carolina. Espy had disappeared when her youngest daughter was just six weeks old. The identification brought some closure to her family but also reignited questions about her untimely death. ...Read More

Share

Comments (0)

Leave A Comment