Vanished in the Night: The Unsolved Disappearance of Stacie Madison and Susan Smalley

A Spring Break That Turned Into a Lifelong Nightmare

In the early hours of March 20, 1988, two best friends from Carrollton, Texas—17-year-old Stacie Madison and 18-year-old Susan Smalley—vanished without a trace. The two high school seniors were last seen in Madison’s distinctive green and gold 1967 Ford Mustang convertible, a car painted in the colors of their school, Newman Smith High. Their disappearance has haunted their families and the community for decades, remaining one of North Texas's most enduring cold cases.

The Final Hours: A Timeline of Events

On the evening of March 19, 1988, Stacie and Susan planned a sleepover at Susan’s home. After picking up Susan’s mother from work at a department store, the girls returned to Susan's house, changed clothes, and went out again. They were seen attempting to purchase alcohol at a 7-Eleven but were denied due to their age. Later, they visited the Steak and Ale restaurant in Addison, where Susan worked. Susan briefly spoke with a coworker while Stacie waited in the car. This was the last confirmed sighting of the girls.

Discovery of the Abandoned Mustang

Two days after their disappearance, Stacie’s Mustang was found locked and abandoned in a strip mall parking lot at Forest Lane and Webb Chapel Road in Dallas. The vehicle appeared undisturbed, with personal items belonging to both girls inside, including a portable stereo. Forest Lane was a popular cruising spot for teens at the time, adding to the mystery of their disappearance.

Initial Investigation and Missteps

Initially, authorities treated the case as a possible runaway situation, leading to delays in the investigation. Crucially, the Mustang was not forensically examined for fingerprints or DNA evidence, a decision that has been widely criticized in hindsight. Detective Greg Ward, who took over the case months later, acknowledged that the initial team may have had "tunnel vision" in their approach. ...Read More

Share

Comments (0)

Leave A Comment