Josephine Chatraw Missing Person Case

Josephine Chatraw, a 36-year-old mother of five, was last seen on July 29, 1984, in Syracuse, New York. On the night of her disappearance, she spoke to her sister from her home on Seymour Street, expressing distress over a disagreement with her boyfriend, Philip Whaley. This was the last known contact anyone had with her, and she was reported missing on August 3, 1984.

Chatraw had a tumultuous relationship with Whaley, and on the night she vanished, a neighbor reported seeing Whaley physically assaulting her and dragging her back into his apartment. Whaley later claimed that after an argument, Chatraw left on her own, and he saw her walking alone on Seymour Street. However, she was never seen again.

In the years following her disappearance, Whaley became the prime suspect. He had been arrested weeks earlier for unlawfully imprisoning and assaulting Chatraw. In 1996, Whaley was convicted of her murder, despite her body never being found. Whaley was also convicted for the murder of another woman, Margaret Reiley, who disappeared in 1992. Though Whaley later confessed to causing Chatraw's death, efforts to locate her remains were unsuccessful.

This case remains one of the significant cold cases in Syracuse, with Chatraw's body yet to be recovered, though foul play is suspected. Whaley continues to serve a life sentence for both murders.
Last Seen: Jul 29, 1984

Police in Amboy look for bodies of murdered women - Syracuse.com">Police in Amboy look for bodies of murdered women - Syracuse.com

Missing Person / NamUs #MP7593 - Office of Justice Programs

Josephine Carroll Chatraw - The Charley Project

2448DFNY - Josephine Carroll Chatraw - Doe Network

After 18 years, police searching for victims' bodies in Oswego County

4 girls missing 1979-1985 - Porchlight International for the ... - Tapatalk

Margaret Reiley - The Charley Project

Police searching for remains of Philip Whaley murder victims