Crime Solvers Central
CSC
254 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Justin Dwayne Baker, a 41-year-old Army veteran from Muldrow, Oklahoma, was reported missing on January 24, 2025, following a vehicle accident in the early morning hours. Around 3 to 4 a.m., a Jeep carrying Baker and two others crashed into the Arkansas River near the Paw Paw Bottoms area in Sequoyah County. The driver, identified as Newt Holland, and another passenger managed to escape and were treated for injuries at a local hospital. However, Baker did not resurface and has remained missing s ...Read More
Last Seen: Jan 24, 2025

Links to Additional Sources (0)

See any mistakes? Let us know!

Victim Details

Apr 03, 2025

Apr 15, 2025

Justin

Baker

41

41

73 inches

248 lbs

American Indian / Alaska Native

Male

In the early morning hours of January 24, 2025, the life of 41-year-old Justin Dwayne Baker, a resident of Muldrow, Oklahoma, took an unforeseen and tragic turn. A former combat veteran and a devoted father, Justin was last seen leaving a bar in Fort Smith, Arkansas, with two acquaintances. Instead of heading home, the group went on a drive to Muldrow Bottoms, a local area known for off-roading. There, in the darkness, the vehicle plunged into the frigid waters of the Arkansas River. While the two other occupants managed to escape the submerged vehicle and swim to the shore, Justin did not surface and has not been seen or heard from since. The days and weeks that followed Justin's disappearance were marked by intensive search and rescue operations. The Oklahoma Highway Patrol, along with their marine division and search and rescue dogs, the Fort Smith and Arkoma Fire Departments, and the Cherokee Nation Marshals, all took part in the extensive search. The vehicle was recovered from the river, but there was no trace of Justin. His family, including his mother, Kelly Cox, has been a constant presence at the search sites, holding onto hope for his return. Community members and volunteer organizations also joined the efforts, utilizing sonar technology and conducting dives in the river to aid in the search for the missing Army veteran and citizen of the Cherokee Nation. As months have passed without any sign of Justin, his case remains an active and ongoing investigation. His family and advocacy groups, such as Northeastern Oklahoma Indigenous Safety & Education (NOISE), have continued to push for public awareness and have urged that the case be turned over to the FBI, citing the fact that Justin was last seen in Arkansas before the incident in Oklahoma. The Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation is assisting with the investigation into what they have termed a suspicious disappearance. The family continues to plead for any information that could lead to finding Justin, as the uncertainty surrounding his fate weighs heavily on them and the community. The case is an overview of a night that began with friends at a bar and ended in a mysterious and heartbreaking disappearance in the Arkansas River, leaving a family desperate for answers and a community hoping for closure.

Jan 24, 2025

Muldrow

Oklahoma

Sequoyah County

Muldrow

Yes

166616

Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation - Southeast Investigative Regional Office

McAlester

Oklahoma

Pittsburg County

74501

701 W. Carl Albert Parkway McAlester, OK 74501, Oklahoma

5802985525

State

Law Enforcement

OSBI2025-179

Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation - Southeast Investigative Regional Office

9404

Brown

Blue

Blue

06/19/2026


Area Last Seen: