- Home
- Cases
- Get Involved
- Community
- Tools
- Info
-
Account
- NOT A MEMBER
Become a Member! - LOGIN
- NOT A MEMBER
- Search Cases

Paul James
ELLIOTT
65
20
70 inches
70 inches
161 lbs
161 lbs
White / Caucasian
Male
In the late summer of 2007, a quiet street in Alliance, Ohio, became the starting point of an enduring mystery. On August 22nd, 50-year-old Paul Ellis Elliott vanished after a seemingly minor incident. That day, one of his brothers contacted the Alliance Police to report that some tools had been stolen from a shed on the property they shared. Paul, who was reportedly uncomfortable around law enforcement due to a past event, chose to leave before the officers arrived. He rode away on his bicycle and was never heard from again. He was not considered a suspect in the theft; his family believes someone else was responsible. At the time of his disappearance, Paul was described as being between 5'6" and 5'8" tall, weighing around 150 to 165 pounds, with brown hair and brown eyes. He also contended with personal challenges, including schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. In the initial days and weeks following Paul's disappearance, his family was understandably worried. His son, Bryan, searched the places his father was known to frequent and checked a rural trailer property Paul sometimes visited, but the trailer was locked with no sign of Paul or his bicycle. As time stretched on with no contact, a strange and unsubstantiated rumor began to circulate that Paul had traveled to Alaska to start a new life. This story gave some family members a glimmer of hope, but to others, it seemed unlikely. The theory that he had left voluntarily was contradicted by the essential personal items he left behind, including his wallet, phone, identification, and Social Security card—possessions someone would certainly need to begin a new chapter far from home. His family also noted he was eagerly anticipating his son's upcoming wedding, an event they firmly believe he would never have intentionally missed. The investigation into Paul's disappearance took a dramatic turn in January 2013, nearly six years after he was last seen. In a discovery that shattered the long-held Alaska rumor, Paul's son found his father's bicycle hidden away in the back room of the locked trailer on a property in Atwater, Ohio, about nine miles from where he was last seen. The bike appeared to have been deliberately concealed. This finding fundamentally changed the complexion of the case, suggesting that whatever happened to Paul occurred much closer to home and dispelling the notion that he had ridden off to a distant location. The case remains an agonizing puzzle for his loved ones and investigators. The initial belief was that he fled out of a deep-seated fear of law enforcement, but the discovery of his carefully hidden bicycle years later introduced a more sinister and perplexing element to his story. More than a decade later, the question of what happened to Paul Elliott after he pedaled away down his street remains unanswered, leaving a void in the lives of those who continue to wait for answers.
Pants Brown, Corduroy, May have been wearing corduroy pants Pants Blue, JEANS, May have been wearing jeans Shirt Blue, T-SHIRT, The brand may have possibly been Levis Shoes Suede, Other
Dec 27, 1980
Niagara Falls
Ontario
Niagara Regional Police Service
Niagara Regional
Ontario
905-688-4111
905-688-4111
Law Enforcement
1980-72787
Niagara Regional Police Service
Brown
Blue
Blue
Build: Medium; Complexion: Light/Fair; Hair details: Blonde, Other
No
Read full forum posts and contribute to this case discussion.
Unlock forum access — $3.97/month