Account
Aug 22, 2021
May 20, 2024
Fredrick
Mitchell
37
33
70 inches
150 lbs
White / Caucasian
Male
In the late summer of 2020, a 33-year-old man named Fredrick "Freddy" Mitchell vanished from Edmond, Oklahoma, leaving behind a trail of unanswered questions. Known to his loved ones as a man with short blond hair, blue eyes, and a tattoo on his right pectoral muscle, Fredrick was last seen around September 9, 2020. At the time of his disappearance, he stood about five feet ten inches tall and weighed around 150 pounds. He was not alone when he disappeared; he was in the company of another man, Phillip Smith, whose own vanishing act would become intertwined with Fredrick's, deepening the mystery that continues to haunt their families and investigators. The circumstances surrounding the disappearance of Fredrick and Phillip soon pointed toward a sinister conclusion. Foul play was suspected by authorities as details emerged from informants. These sources connected the men's disappearance to a notorious two-and-a-half-acre compound in Logan County known as the "bully farm". The investigation uncovered a disturbing theory suggesting that Phillip's own brother, Mikell "Bulldog" Smith, a convicted murderer serving time in prison, may have ordered a hit on him. The alleged motive was rooted in Mikell's anger over Phillip bringing homeless individuals to their mother's house, fearing she might contract COVID-19. Informants claimed that Fredrick and Phillip had been lured to a party at the "bully farm" where they were ultimately killed. As the investigation progressed, law enforcement searched several locations, uncovering bone fragments at the "bully farm," a nearby secondary site, and an oil field road. These discoveries offered a grim possibility but did not provide immediate answers, as the complex process of identification began. Despite the compelling and disturbing witness statements and the grim discoveries, the case grew more complex without a definitive breakthrough. The Logan County Sheriff's Office has continued its investigation into the disappearances, but no charges have been filed in connection with the missing men. The case of Fredrick Mitchell is a harrowing story of a man who disappeared under suspicious and violent circumstances, leaving his family in a state of perpetual uncertainty, waiting for justice and closure.
Sep 09, 2020
Edmond
Oklahoma
Logan County
73034
No
106672
Logan County Sheriff's Office
Guthrie
Oklahoma
Logan County
73044
216 South Broad Street, Guthrie, Oklahoma 73044, Oklahoma
4052824100
County
Law Enforcement
2021-0825
2021-06-30
Logan County Sheriff's Office
Blond/Strawberry
Blue
Blue
06/20/2026
