Anthony Neil Biggerstaff, 45, was killed in Spartanburg County, South Carolina, in late spring 2016. His car was found partially submerged in Lake Bowen on May 30, 2016, with blood in the back seat and a gunshot through a rear passenger window. He had been reported missing days earlier. His body was recovered under a bridge on Jordan Road on June 2, 2016; investigators determined the cause of death was a gunshot wound to the head.

Two people from Inman, Brittany Cassandra Foster, 22, and Keenan Hines, 23, who had associated with and at one point lived with Biggerstaff, were identified as suspects. Foster later admitted she turned from the front passenger seat and shot Biggerstaff four times while he sat in the back. Hines admitted giving Foster the .380-caliber pistol after she talked about wanting to get rid of Biggerstaff, led deputies to where the body had been left, and the weapon was later recovered after he said he had taken it to a family member.

Foster pleaded guilty to murder and possession of a weapon during a violent crime and received a 40-year prison sentence. Did anyone who knew Anthony or his associates see signs of trouble before May 2016?