April Delores Infinger, 32, was killed on December 8, 2013, after a gunshot from outside the Moonshine Saloon in Goose Creek, South Carolina, penetrated the building’s wall and struck her. She was at the saloon celebrating a friend’s birthday when a dispute inside spilled into the parking lot; April was an innocent bystander and later died at a local hospital.

Investigators arrested 33-year-old Shearon Lamar Bennett after learning he had been involved in the altercation, had been removed by bouncers, and then fired a weapon from the parking lot. Bennett was initially charged with murder; he later pleaded guilty to involuntary manslaughter and discharging a firearm into a dwelling and received a 15-year prison sentence. The court heard emotional testimony from April’s family.

Two others, Darrell Bennett (identified as Shearon Bennett’s brother) and April Cartin, were charged with obstruction of justice in connection with the investigation.