Sandra Suzzane Shapiro Laplace, 27, vanished on the evening of May 1, 1974, in Hull Bay, St. Thomas. A mother of two who had moved from New York with her husband Randy, she left home around 9:00 p.m., drove a short distance and disappeared. Her car was found abandoned near a bar not far from the house; Sandra, her purse, and her keys were missing. She was described as a Caucasian female, brown hair, hazel eyes, 5 feet 3 inches tall, 125 pounds.

In the months before she vanished Sandra had felt homesick and had briefly returned to New York before coming back in January 1974. Family members say she had told her husband she felt overwhelmed; he gave inconsistent accounts about whether they argued the night she left. Some relatives believe she may have intended to return to New York and note she reportedly had a significant amount of cash, but checks with local airports and airboat services produced no evidence she departed the island. The original report was later destroyed in a fire or flood and a new report was filed; the case remains open and the family has pursued leads, including unconfirmed sightings in the early 1980s.

Did anyone in Hull Bay or St. Thomas see Sandra or her car on the night of May 1, 1974, or have information about where she might have gone afterward?