Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 cases solved Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Share what you know: tips, sources, questions and theories about this case. Be respectful; abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

2 discussions · 2 posts

Mary Jean Olshefski-Beatty, 56, of Gerrardstown, West Virginia, was last seen on March 4, 2011, walking away…

EK EK

Mary Jean Olshefski-Beatty, 56, of Gerrardstown, West Virginia, was last seen on March 4, 2011, walking away from her home on Jenkins Road and has not been heard from since. At disappearance she was wearing a blue Carhartt t-shirt, tan shorts, and black sandals. A nearly yearlong delay in filing a missing person report is noted and has been linked to a long history of drug addiction; that history reportedly made earlier, shorter disappearances common but family say this absence was uncharacteristic.

She lived on a property with her daughter and the daughter’s boyfriend at the time she vanished. Investigators found blood on the living room floor of the home; the blood reportedly has not been tested. Olshefski-Beatty has graying blonde hair, blue eyes, pierced ears, wears reading glasses, and has several scars and tattoos, including a Caesarean scar, a forehead scar, a burn scar on her left breast, a scarred-over butterfly tattoo on her breast, and a Pegasus with three or four stars on the inside of her ankle. She may also have used the names Alice Cook and Carol Martin.

Does anyone remember seeing Mary Jean around Gerrardstown in early March 2011 or know anyone who used those aliases?

18 Reply Report

Mary Beatty, 56, of Gerrardstown, West Virginia, was reported missing on March 4, 2011.

FI FI

Mary Beatty, 56, of Gerrardstown, West Virginia, was reported missing on March 4, 2011. She was last seen in the Gerrardstown area; the circumstances of her disappearance prompted immediate concern and urgent search efforts by family and friends.

In the days after she vanished, relatives and friends organized searches, distributed flyers, and used social media to raise awareness. Local law enforcement interviewed acquaintances and searched nearby locations but initial efforts did not produce significant leads. As weeks became months without credible sightings or substantive evidence, the investigation faced ongoing challenges and the family’s urgency grew.

The case has remained open and has drawn local media attention; family members have held vigils and community events to keep her name in the public eye. If anyone in Gerrardstown or the surrounding area remembers Mary or has information about where she might have been on or after March 4, 2011, please come forward.

18 Reply Report