Sy Ray’s Sworn Affidavit Raises Serious Questions About the Cellphone Evidence
I've been reviewing the sworn affidavit submitted by defense expert Sy Ray on March 26, 2025, regarding the AT&T Timing Advance records in the University of Idaho homicide investigation.
Ray raises serious concerns about missing cellphone records, the FBI's ability to obtain those records, and what prosecutors knew about their availability.
What really caught my attention was page 9 of the PDF, particularly paragraph 1(c) under the Conclusion and the statements immediately following it.
Ray alleges that prosecutor Ashley Jennings knowingly misrepresented the availability of AT&T Timing Advance records to the court and concealed potentially exculpatory evidence. He goes on to explain that in nearly 30 years of working with prosecutors, he had never witnessed such an attempt to mislead a court.
Those are incredibly serious allegations coming from an expert who spent much of his career working with law enforcement and prosecutors.
I encourage everyone to read pages 7–9 of the affidavit, particularly page 9, and draw their own conclusions.
Were these allegations ever adequately addressed? What happened to the missing records? And why wouldn't concerns of this magnitude warrant further examination?
I'm not suggesting that an allegation automatically establishes misconduct, but I do believe sworn statements like these deserve scrutiny, regardless of anyone's opinion about Kohberger's guilt or innocence. The victims and their families deserve an investigation whose evidence can withstand that scrutiny.
Source: Sy Ray's sworn affidavit regarding AT&T Timing Advance Records, filed March 26, 2025, State v. Kohberger. See PDF pages 7–9, particularly page 9, for his allegations concerning prosecutorial conduct.
https://coi.isc.idaho.gov/docs/CR01-24-31665/2025/032625%2BDefendants%2BNotice%2Bof%2BFiling%2BAffidavit%2Biso%2BObj%2Bto%2Bthe%2BStates%2BMIL%2BRE%2BATT%2BTiming%2BAdvance%2BRecords.pdf

