Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 cases solved Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Share what you know: tips, sources, questions and theories about this case. Be respectful; abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

2 discussions · 9 posts

Sy Ray’s Sworn Affidavit Raises Serious Questions About the Cellphone Evidence

+AC AC · 7 replies, last Nov 19, 2026

I've been reviewing the sworn affidavit submitted by defense expert Sy Ray on March 26, 2025, regarding the AT&T Timing Advance records in the University of Idaho homicide investigation.

Ray raises serious concerns about missing cellphone records, the FBI's ability to obtain those records, and what prosecutors knew about their availability.

What really caught my attention was page 9 of the PDF, particularly paragraph 1(c) under the Conclusion and the statements immediately following it.

Ray alleges that prosecutor Ashley Jennings knowingly misrepresented the availability of AT&T Timing Advance records to the court and concealed potentially exculpatory evidence. He goes on to explain that in nearly 30 years of working with prosecutors, he had never witnessed such an attempt to mislead a court.

Those are incredibly serious allegations coming from an expert who spent much of his career working with law enforcement and prosecutors.

I encourage everyone to read pages 7–9 of the affidavit, particularly page 9, and draw their own conclusions.

Were these allegations ever adequately addressed? What happened to the missing records? And why wouldn't concerns of this magnitude warrant further examination?

I'm not suggesting that an allegation automatically establishes misconduct, but I do believe sworn statements like these deserve scrutiny, regardless of anyone's opinion about Kohberger's guilt or innocence. The victims and their families deserve an investigation whose evidence can withstand that scrutiny.

Source: Sy Ray's sworn affidavit regarding AT&T Timing Advance Records, filed March 26, 2025, State v. Kohberger. See PDF pages 7–9, particularly page 9, for his allegations concerning prosecutorial conduct.

https://coi.isc.idaho.gov/docs/CR01-24-31665/2025/032625%2BDefendants%2BNotice%2Bof%2BFiling%2BAffidavit%2Biso%2BObj%2Bto%2Bthe%2BStates%2BMIL%2BRE%2BATT%2BTiming%2BAdvance%2BRecords.pdf

8 Reply Message Report
+BJ BJ

There is just way too much evidence for even the smallest chance he is not guilty. These 4 innocent people lost their lives to this monster. I think in any case you can pick apart mistakes that police, detectives, prosecutors make but you can't just choose to ignore the overwhelming evidence to look for some conspiracy. Just my 2 cents. https://www.reddit.com/r/MoscowMurders/comments/1v9pdk0/confirmed_case_evidence_as_of_july_2026/?share_id=Tk8yyq7F2djQzTKl7a4wS&utm_content=share_button&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_source=share&utm_term=1

16 Reply Message Report
+AC AC

I appreciate your response and respect that we have different opinions. I reviewed the Reddit summary you provided, but I noticed several discrepancies between what is presented as confirmed evidence and what is actually contained in the court documents.

Here are just a few examples:

#10 – The 23 visits near King Road: Sy Ray's sworn affidavit filed March 26, 2025, regarding FBI Agent Nicholas Ballance's testimony specifically challenges the cellular analysis supporting those alleged visits.

#1–3 – DNA evidence: Judge Hippler's April 18, 2025 order regarding Rylene Nowlin and touch DNA discusses the limitations of determining when and how DNA was deposited, including the possibility of secondary transfer. Identifying a DNA contributor does not establish the circumstances under which the DNA was deposited.

#16–21 – Vehicle identification: Defense expert Steven Becker's report, filed January 23, 2025 (Exhibit D2-B, Bates pages 3163–3183), challenges conclusions drawn from the surveillance footage and vehicle identification.

#33 – Blood transfer: Defense crime scene reconstruction expert Chris Noedel's report (Bates page 003287) discusses the potential for blood transfer and the absence of recovered forensic evidence connecting Kohberger's vehicle and apartment to the victims.

#50 – No alibi submitted: The defense's March 17, 2025 filing, page 2, documents that a Notice of Alibi was filed on July 24, 2023, followed by a supplemental response on April 17, 2024. Whether the alibi was sufficient is an entirely different question from whether one was submitted.

These are just a few examples. The Reddit summary combines documented forensic findings, disputed expert interpretations, circumstantial evidence, character allegations and speculation under the heading of confirmed evidence.

I understand that reading through thousands of pages of investigative reports, expert findings and court filings is time-consuming. I've followed this case extensively since November 2022 and have repeatedly encountered significant differences between the mainstream media narrative and the actual source documents.

I also don't believe that questioning the integrity of an investigation or examining sworn allegations of prosecutorial misconduct constitutes looking for a conspiracy.

My original post specifically addressed Sy Ray's sworn allegations on page 9 of his March 26, 2025 affidavit. The Reddit summary doesn't address those allegations.

Regardless of whether we believe Kohberger is guilty, shouldn't we all be concerned about allegations that potentially exculpatory evidence was withheld or misrepresented to the court?

I will continue to read the original source documents and expert findings rather than rely on Reddit, social media or mainstream media summaries to form my conclusions. I respect your right to reach a different conclusion and appreciate the discussion.

Original source documents:

Sy Ray's affidavit regarding FBI expert testimony:

https://coi.isc.idaho.gov/docs/CR01-24-31665/2025/032625%2BDefendants%2BNotice%2Bof%2BFiling%2BAffidavit%2Biso%2BMIL%2B2%2BRE%2BVague%2BUndisclosed%2BExpert%2BTestimony.pdf

Judge Hippler's April 18, 2025 DNA ruling:

https://coi.isc.idaho.gov/docs/CR01-24-31665/2025/041825%2BOrder%2Bon%2BDefendants%2BMotion%2Bin%2BLimine%2BRE%2BRylene%2BNowlin%2Band%2BTouch%2Band%2BContact%2BDNA.pdf

January 23, 2025 defense expert reports (Becker and Noedel):

https://coi.isc.idaho.gov/docs/CR01-24-31665/2025/012325%2BREDACTED%2BExhibits%2Bto%2BDefendants%2BSupplemental%2BResponse%2Bto%2BRequest%2Bfor%2BDiscovery%2BRe%2BExpert%2BW.pdf

March 17, 2025 defense alibi filing:

https://coi.isc.idaho.gov/docs/CR01-24-31665/2025/031725-Defendants-Obj-States-MiL-Alibi.pdf

0 Reply Message Report
+AC AC

I'd also like to add some context regarding the alleged 23 visits. Bryan lived in Pullman, Washington, approximately 10–15 minutes from Moscow, Idaho. As a North Idaho resident, I can appreciate how common it is for WA residents to cross the state line for groceries, shopping, fuel and dining, particularly given the differences in taxes and prices.

I would encourage you to review FBI Special Agent Nicholas Ballance's CAST report and his subsequent disclosures dated December 18, 2024, February 17, 2025, and March 3, 2025.

The defense's March 24, 2025 filing specifically addresses slides 29 and 30 of Ballance's presentation and points out that the dates of the alleged visits changed over the course of his analysis. The defense also challenged the lack of supporting analysis for those conclusions.

Even prosecutor Bill Thompson acknowledged during the July 2, 2025 plea hearing that the tower serviced numerous residences and that they had no evidence of direct contact with 1122 King Road or its occupants.

There is a significant difference between connecting to a cellular tower that provides coverage to a residence and establishing that someone actually visited or surveilled that residence.

What evidence establishes that his previous trips to Moscow had anything to do with the victims?

Source: Defense's March 24, 2025 reply regarding vague and undisclosed expert testimony:

https://coi.isc.idaho.gov/docs/CR01-24-31665/2025/032425-Defendants-Reply-States-Response-Defs-MIL2-RE-Vague-Undisclosed-Expert-Testimony.pdf

Additional source: Judge Hippler's April 24, 2025 order, page 3, identifying Ballance's three expert disclosures:

https://coi.isc.idaho.gov/docs/CR01-24-31665/2025/042425%2BOrder%2Bon%2BDefendants%2BMotion%2Bin%2BLimine%2BRE%2BVague%2Band%2BUndisclosed%2BExpert%2BTestimony.pdf

1 Reply Message Report
+BJ BJ

AC, I appreciate your thoughtful response and can agree that we can have a considerate discussion with opposing views. It just seems really sus to me that those 23 visits to Moscow all happened between 10pm and 4am and none of them related to any charges or transactions for shopping trips or any other reasons. Even at that, I don't think someone would be driving that far and passing several other grocery options to go shopping. HIs phone turned off while traveling towards Moscow just before the murders then turned back on after the murders. Just too much evidence pointing to his guilt. I think he thought he was too smart to get caught and he was wrong.

0 Reply Message Report
+AC AC

I genuinely appreciate that we can have a respectful discussion despite our differing opinions. I am absolutely willing to change my position if the evidence supports that change. However, what has been publicly released so far is not enough for me to conclude guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

There are too many inconsistencies, omissions, allegations of data manipulation and questionable departures from investigative policies. If these were simply honest mistakes by law enforcement or prosecutors, why weren't more of them acknowledged and corrected? Why were disputed or potentially inaccurate representations made to establish probable cause?

Here are some of the issues I continue to struggle with:

• The murder weapon was never recovered. How can we conclusively identify a Ka-Bar as the weapon used? There are forensic findings and differing expert interpretations of the victims' injuries that I believe warrant further examination regarding the possibility of multiple weapons or perpetrators.

• There is no continuous surveillance footage establishing that the white vehicles in the various videos were all the same vehicle. There are apparent discrepancies involving exterior features, including fog lights. FBI vehicle identification specialist Anthony Imel initially identified the vehicle as a 2011–2013 Hyundai Elantra. Bryan owned a 2015. Defense expert Steven Becker also challenged the vehicle identification.

• There are conflicting accounts concerning the discovery and location of the knife sheath, including references to the floor and its location on the bed near Madison. Why are there discrepancies in the documentation of arguably the most significant piece of physical evidence?

• The investigative genetic genealogy process raises questions regarding compliance with applicable policies and GEDmatch's privacy restrictions. Those concerns deserve examination rather than dismissal.

• The DNA recovered from the sheath does not establish when or how it was deposited. I encourage you to research the Lukis Anderson case, which demonstrates how secondary DNA transfer can implicate someone who was not present at a crime scene.

• We have repeatedly been told Bryan purchased a Ka-Bar knife and sheath. Where is the original transaction receipt documenting that specific purchase? Browsing history, purchase records and proof of possession are different things.

• What original device extraction data establishes that Bryan manually powered off his phone? His historical phone usage and reported pattern of shutting it off are relevant context. A gap in cellular activity alone does not establish intent.

• The exact time Xana and Ethan returned to the residence remains uncertain. How confident can we be in the State's reconstruction when portions of the timeline remain unresolved?

• Sy Ray's sworn allegations concerning potentially exculpatory cellular records and representations made to the court remain particularly concerning to me.

Much of the additional information listed in the Reddit summary is either circumstantial, disputed, missing important context or lacks publicly available supporting documentation. Circumstantial evidence can absolutely support a conviction, but that doesn't mean every suspicious-looking activity necessarily supports guilt.

I feel we have to dismiss or explain away a considerable number of discrepancies to accept the State's narrative. I'm not comfortable operating on a "trust us" mentality when we're talking about incarcerating a fellow American for the remainder of his life or potentially executing him. I want to see the proof.

Bryan maintained a not-guilty plea for nearly three years while his defense raised numerous discovery concerns. Now that he is challenging his conviction and alleging coercion surrounding his plea, I hope those issues receive meaningful judicial review.

I would welcome a trial where the evidence could be presented, independently examined and subjected to cross-examination. I would also welcome evidence that conclusively resolves my concerns, even if it proves my current position wrong.

My position isn't about defending Bryan at the expense of the victims. It's about holding the justice system accountable and ensuring that every person responsible for these homicides is held accountable.

In my opinion, until these significant questions are adequately addressed, Xana, Ethan, Maddie and Kaylee have not received the justice they deserve.

1 Reply Message Report
+AC AC

You mentioned that you believe Bryan thought he was too smart to get caught. That's actually another aspect of this case that I struggle with.

We're being asked to believe that someone with his educational background in criminology and knowledge of cloud forensics made some of the most basic and incriminating mistakes imaginable. He allegedly drove his own vehicle to commit four murders, passing numerous surveillance cameras, brought his personal cellphone, entered a house in the Greek Row area during a busy college weekend with multiple vehicles parked outside, left a knife sheath behind and left two surviving occupants, one of whom reported seeing a masked individual.

Yet somehow, despite all of these seemingly careless mistakes, he allegedly committed four incredibly violent murders without leaving any other DNA identified as his at the crime scene or transferring any detectable DNA from the victims to his vehicle, apartment or other personal belongings.

How does someone demonstrate that level of forensic awareness while simultaneously making so many fundamental mistakes?

You mentioned that we can't simply choose to ignore overwhelming evidence to look for a conspiracy. I would respectfully argue that this works both ways. We shouldn't dismiss inconsistencies, conflicting forensic findings, missing evidence or questionable investigative practices simply because we've accepted someone's guilt.

I'm not suggesting that educated people are incapable of making stupid mistakes, nor am I suggesting that these circumstances independently establish his innocence. I'm saying that when I consider the totality of the evidence, there is simply too much to reconcile on the other side as well.

Questioning evidence isn't looking for a conspiracy. It's applying the same level of scrutiny to the prosecution's narrative that we would apply to any alternative explanation. I think both deserve to be held to the same evidentiary standard.

0 Reply Message Report
Latest reply
+BJ BJ

So this guy with his educational background in criminology and knowledge of forensics pleads guilty to 4 murders and that's what? A false confession? Come on.. I mean really.. come on. If he really knows that much about criminology he would know how hard it is to overturn a false confession. I'm sure you'll have some rationale for why he did that as well but at some point you're not really following the evidence. You've made up your mind and then you're looking at all of the evidence from an angle to support your conclusion.

2 Reply Message Report

Xana Kernodle was a 20-year-old University of Idaho junior studying marketing when she was killed in the…

+UB UB

Xana Kernodle was a 20-year-old University of Idaho junior studying marketing when she was killed in the pre-dawn hours of November 13, 2022, in an off-campus rental home on King Road in Moscow, Idaho. She and her boyfriend, 20-year-old Ethan Chapin, were staying on the third floor with roommates Madison Mogen and Kaylee Goncalves; all four were stabbed to death in an attack investigators estimate lasted about 25 minutes. Two roommates on the first floor were unharmed, apparently asleep during the incident.

Autopsy findings show Xana suffered numerous stab wounds, many of them defensive, indicating she fought back. A military-style knife and a sheath left at the scene produced DNA evidence and other investigative leads. Authorities later arrested 28-year-old Bryan Christopher Kohberger in Pennsylvania and charged him with four counts of first-degree murder and burglary. Prosecutors initially sought the death penalty; Kohberger ultimately pleaded guilty on July 2, 2025, and received four consecutive life sentences without parole plus 10 years. The motive for the killings has not been made public.

Did anyone who knew Xana, her social circle at the university, or the neighborhood notice anything unusual in the days before November 13, 2022?

18 Reply Message Report