Share what you know: tips, sources, questions and theories about this case. Be respectful; abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.
Start a discussion about Mary Ann Bagenstose
2 discussions · 2 posts
Mary Ann Bagenstose was 25 when she was last seen at her West Willow, Pennsylvania home on June 5, 1984.
IMIM
Mary Ann Bagenstose was 25 when she was last seen at her West Willow, Pennsylvania home on June 5, 1984. Separated from her husband Jere and involved in a custody dispute over their two-year-old son, she reportedly left a note saying she was walking to a local market; employees at the store later said they did not see her that day. Her mother reported her missing two days later.
Investigators noted several troubling inconsistencies. Jere said he had taken their son to a park that morning and later returned to find Mary Ann gone; he also claimed to have discarded the note he said she left. Nothing of Mary Ann’s personal property was missing from the house. An officer observed fresh dirt in the garage covered by cardboard; a search uncovered a hole about three feet by six feet and five feet deep, but no body was found.
What can readers who knew Mary Ann or saw her in West Willow around June 5, 1984, add to this timeline?
Mary Ann Bagenstose was 25 when she disappeared from West Willow, Pennsylvania.
JHJH
Mary Ann Bagenstose was 25 when she disappeared from West Willow, Pennsylvania. She was last seen on June 5, 1984, living separately from her husband, Jere Bagenstose, and caring for their two-year-old son while a boarder also lived in the house. That morning she had plans to go car shopping with Jere; he says he took the child to a park and found Mary Ann gone when he returned. He told investigators he found a note saying she had walked to a nearby market, but store employees who knew her did not recall seeing her and Jere says he disposed of the note.
Mary Ann’s mother reported her missing on June 7, 1984, after two days without contact. Investigators later found a freshly dug rectangular hole in the garage, hidden under cardboard; Jere gave differing explanations about it. There was no activity on Mary Ann’s bank accounts and no one has heard from her since. In December 2022 Jere Bagenstose was arrested and charged with criminal homicide; forensic handwriting analysis later attributed the alleged note to him rather than Mary Ann.
Who in West Willow remembers Mary Ann, her routines, or that day in June 1984 and might have information to help clarify what happened?