Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 cases solved Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Share what you know: tips, sources, questions and theories about this case. Be respectful; abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

2 discussions · 2 posts

Carolyn Elizabeth Lawson, 25, was abducted from her Jasper, Alabama, home in the pre-dawn hours of September…

SG SG

Carolyn Elizabeth Lawson, 25, was abducted from her Jasper, Alabama, home in the pre-dawn hours of September 11, 1991. A woman claiming to be a hospital nurse summoned Lawson and her husband outside; as they approached their vehicle a masked man with a gun forced Lawson to tie up her husband, then drove off with her in her 1991 Ford Explorer. A ransom demand for $300,000 followed. The family left money where instructed; the ransom was picked up on September 13, but Lawson was never released.

Her Ford Explorer was found more than a week later in a wooded area of Winston County. Investigation identified two suspects, Jerry Bland and his distant cousin Karen McPherson. Bland died by suicide roughly three weeks after the abduction as law enforcement closed in; much of the ransom was found hidden in his attic. McPherson was arrested and later pleaded guilty to involvement, saying she last saw Lawson a day or two after the kidnapping and that Bland told her Lawson had escaped into remote woods. Despite searches of abandoned coal mines and numerous tips over the years, no trace of Lawson has been found; she was declared legally dead in 1993.

What leads or overlooked locations might still point to Carolyn Lawson’s whereabouts?

18 Reply Report

Carolyn Carrie Lawson was 25 when she was abducted from her Jasper, Alabama, home in the early morning of…

RJ RJ

Carolyn Carrie Lawson was 25 when she was abducted from her Jasper, Alabama, home in the early morning of September 11, 1991. A woman who later identified herself as Karen McPherson placed a deceptive call about a family emergency, drawing Carrie and her husband Earl outside. A masked gunman then forced Carrie to bind Earl with duct tape and drove off in Carrie’s Ford Explorer.

A $300,000 ransom demand followed; the family left the money at the instructed location and the kidnapper took it, but Carrie was never returned. McPherson later admitted making the call and guarding Carrie for a couple of days after the abduction, confirming Carrie was alive then. Distant cousin Jerry Bland was a prime suspect; he killed himself as police closed in and a large portion of the ransom was found in his attic. McPherson was convicted and received life imprisonment but has never revealed what happened to Carrie. Carrie was declared legally dead in 1993, and extensive searches including emptied mines have failed to locate remains. Many investigators and the family suspect a third person may have been involved; abandoned coal mines have been a focal point in the search.

If anyone knew Carrie, her movements around Jasper in September 1991, or has information about abandoned mine activity or contacts who may have been involved, please share what is known.

18 Reply Report