Share what you know: tips, sources, questions and theories about this case. Be respectful; abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.
Start a discussion about Nancy Osullivan
2 discussions · 2 posts
Nancy Marie O’Sullivan was 15 when she vanished from South Holland, Illinois, on March 7, 1974.
JEJE
Nancy Marie O’Sullivan was 15 when she vanished from South Holland, Illinois, on March 7, 1974. Her family had been living in nearby Homewood for about two years; Nancy was visiting a family on the 1300 block of 168th Place in South Holland, next door to her former home, when a friend reported seeing her walk to the end of his driveway and accept a ride in a blue Cadillac. She had a history of brief runaways, but this time she left behind her purse and makeup and did not return.
For more than three decades the case was treated as a runaway, a classification that affected the early investigation. Over time authorities concluded the voluntary-departure theory became less likely and now consider Nancy an endangered missing person and suspect foul play. One person Nancy visited that day was later described as having a drug addiction and another as having a reputation for violence; two of the family’s three sons have died and the third was too young then to provide details. The Homewood Police Department continues to list the case as active and asks anyone with information to get in touch.
Did anyone in the South Holland or Homewood area remember seeing Nancy or that blue Cadillac in March 1974?
Nancy Marie O’Sullivan was 15 when she vanished from South Holland, Illinois, on the evening of Thursday,…
SBSB
Nancy Marie O’Sullivan was 15 when she vanished from South Holland, Illinois, on the evening of Thursday, March 7, 1974. A freshman at Homewood‑Flossmoor High School who lived in nearby Homewood with her parents and ten siblings, she had returned to her family’s former neighborhood to visit friends and was last seen in the 1300 block of East 168th Place. A friend said she walked to the end of his driveway and accepted a ride in a blue Cadillac; she did not return home the next day and was reported missing by her father.
Nancy had run away briefly before but always returned; this time she left her purse and makeup behind, which family called uncharacteristic. The case was long handled as a runaway matter before investigators later reclassified her as endangered missing and came to believe she was the victim of foul play. Several people Nancy had been visiting are now deceased, and police say there is little definitive evidence about her last hours. The Homewood Police Department keeps the investigation open and has issued public appeals for anyone with information.
If anyone knew Nancy, saw a blue Cadillac in that neighborhood on March 7, 1974, or has information that might help, please share what is known with investigators.