Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 cases solved Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Share what you know: tips, sources, questions and theories about this case. Be respectful; abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

2 discussions · 2 posts

On March 25, 1998, five people were shot to death inside a mobile home in Jefferson, Arkansas.

BI BI

On March 25, 1998, five people were shot to death inside a mobile home in Jefferson, Arkansas. Victims were 24-year-old Shelly Marie Erwin Sorg; her children Sean, 5, and Taylor, 3; Shelly’s 20-year-old cousin Misty Erwin; and 12-year-old family friend Samantha Rhodes. They were found inside the residence of Misty’s boyfriend, Clay King Smith.

Two days earlier Misty had reported to the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office that Smith had assaulted her and asked for help to move out, but when deputies arrived she chose to stay. After family members could not reach the household on March 25, deputies went to the home and discovered the killings. Smith was identified as the sole suspect, located near Star City the next day, and engaged in an hour-long standoff while armed with a rifle. Officers shot Smith in the arm and took him into custody; the rifle was later confirmed to be the murder weapon.

Smith was charged with five counts of capital murder, convicted, and sentenced to death. He waived further appeals and was executed on May 8, 2001. Does anyone have additional information about the victims or the timeline in the days before March 25, 1998?

18 Reply Report

On March 25, 1998, five people were found shot to death with a rifle at the Pine Bluff, Arkansas, residence…

KK KK

On March 25, 1998, five people were found shot to death with a rifle at the Pine Bluff, Arkansas, residence of Clay King Smith. Victims included 24-year-old mother Shelley Sorg, her children Sean Michael Sorg, 5, and Taylor Sorg, 3, 20-year-old Misty Erwin (Shelley’s cousin), and 12-year-old family friend Samantha Rhodes. Two days earlier, on March 23, Misty Erwin had called police saying Smith had assaulted her and she needed help leaving; when officers arrived she decided to stay.

After family members reported the group missing, police located the bodies at Smith’s home. A manhunt for Clay King Smith ended on March 26 near Star City in Lincoln County after a standoff in which he reportedly held a rifle later identified as the murder weapon and was shot in the arm by officers when he refused to drop it. He told authorities he had sent three of them to Heaven and two to Hell and later attributed the killings to drugs.

Anyone with information about the case or who knew Shelley, her children, Misty Erwin, or Samantha Rhodes is asked to come forward.

18 Reply Report