On September 27, 2015, authorities in Scottsburg, Indiana, found 69-year-old Bill Reynolds lying in his driveway with a fatal gunshot wound to the head. Reynolds, a White Vietnam War veteran who had recently completed months of treatment at a VA hospital, had returned home amid a difficult divorce and a property dispute with his estranged wife. No weapon was found at the scene, and investigators ruled out suicide and treated the death as a homicide.

Detectives uncovered evidence suggesting the killing had been planned by people close to Reynolds. Investigators reported text messages, surveillance footage, and witness statements that tied four individuals to a conspiracy. The shooting occurred the day Reynolds was to spend his first night alone in the house a judge had awarded him.

Who in Scottsburg remembers Reynolds or saw anything suspicious around Slate Ford Road on or before September 27, 2015?