Sergey Chepchugov, aged 41, tragically lost his life on May 4, 2014, in Naples, Florida, following a violent confrontation with his neighbors, Robert and Deborah Moulton. The incident marked the culmination of a decade-long feud between the two families. On the night of the incident, a dispute erupted over the Moultons' dog barking, leading to a heated exchange between Chepchugov and Deborah Moulton.
According to court records, Deborah Moulton threatened Chepchugov, and her husband, Robert Moulton, intervened with a flashlight. The situation escalated rapidly, with Deborah Moulton shouting threats and Robert Moulton ultimately shooting Chepchugov twice. The entire altercation was captured on the Moultons' security cameras, providing crucial evidence for the investigation.
Following the shooting, Robert and Deborah Moulton barricaded themselves inside their home for several hours. Robert Moulton eventually surrendered to the authorities, while Deborah Moulton had to be forcibly removed by the Collier County Sheriff's Office SWAT team. She was subsequently taken to the hospital after claiming to have ingested several prescription Xanax pills. Both Robert and Deborah Moulton were charged with second-degree murder. Robert Moulton faced additional charges of obstruction of justice, and both were held on substantial bail amounts.
The feud between the Moultons and Chepchugov's family had a long history, with law enforcement being called to their homes 46 times over the years. Neighbors described Deborah Moulton as paranoid and aggressive, often targeting Chepchugov and his wife, Olga Kolesnikova. The tension between the families had escalated to the point where Kolesnikova had previously taken out a restraining order against Deborah Moulton, although it was later dropped. The tragic incident on May 4th brought an end to the ongoing conflict, but it left a lasting impact on the community, with neighbors expressing relief that the Moultons would no longer pose a threat.
The legal proceedings following Chepchugov's death saw both Robert and Deborah Moulton facing serious charges. Deborah Moulton was arraigned for obstruction of justice and second-degree murder, while Robert Moulton faced second-degree murder charges. The case highlighted the severe consequences of prolonged neighborhood disputes and the importance of addressing such conflicts before they escalate to violence. The community mourned the loss of Sergey Chepchugov, a handyman who owned Naples House Services, Inc., and hoped for justice to be served for him and his family.
