Richard Brian “Ricky” Suttles was a bright and compassionate 17-year-old White male with a promising future. Described by his father as a precious and humble child, Ricky was at the top of his class at The Early College at Guilford in High Point, North Carolina. He enjoyed playing basketball and lacrosse and was active in the Royal Rangers, a scouting group where he had earned the Gold Falcon award, its highest honor. Ricky had already received a full academic scholarship to High Point University and was making plans to study math and engineering at North Carolina State University. Earlier in 2011, Ricky and his younger sister, Hannaleigh, had endured the loss of their mother, Carrie Beth Suttles. Following her death, they moved in with their aunt, Mary Ann Holder, in the Pleasant Garden community just south of Greensboro.
The morning of Sunday, November 20, 2011, shattered the lives of Ricky and his family.
His aunt, 36-year-old Mary Ann Holder, embarked on a violent rampage that began around 9:00 a.m. Holder, who was reportedly distraught over the end of an affair with a married man, Randal Lamb, arranged to meet him in the parking lot of an aviation center. There, she shot him twice, inflicting non-life-threatening wounds to his arm. Holder then drove to her home on Cocoa Drive, where Ricky, his 8-year-old sister Hannaleigh, Holder’s 17-year-old son Robert “Dylan” Smith, and Dylan's 15-year-old girlfriend, Makayla Woods, were sleeping. Inside the house, Holder shot all four teenagers in the head.
After the shootings at her home, Holder picked up her younger son, 14-year-old Zachary Smith, from a friend's house. A short time later, around 10:00 a.m., a Guilford County Sheriff's deputy spotted Holder's black Ford Explorer. As the deputy approached the vehicle, Holder died from a self-inflicted gunshot wound. Officers found Zachary in the backseat, also with a critical gunshot wound to the head. When investigators entered the Cocoa Drive home, they discovered Dylan Smith deceased at the scene. Ricky, Hannaleigh, and Makayla were found alive but with devastating injuries. They were rushed to Moses Cone Memorial Hospital in critical condition.
The Guilford County Sheriff’s Office led the investigation into the horrific events. Sheriff B.J. Barnes described it as one of the worst situations he had encountered in his decades-long career. Investigators found two handguns connected to Holder and two notes in which she took responsibility for the shootings and apologized for the pain she had caused. The motive appeared to be linked to the bitter end of her relationship with Lamb, which had involved restraining orders and a threatened "alienation of affection" lawsuit by Lamb's wife. With Holder's suicide, the case was considered closed as the primary suspect was deceased.
In the days that followed the shooting, the community mourned as the death toll rose. Holder's son Zachary and her niece Hannaleigh both succumbed to their injuries at the hospital. Ricky Suttles fought for his life for four days before he passed away from his injuries on Thursday, November 24, 2011, which was Thanksgiving Day. Makayla Woods had died the day before. In total, Mary Ann Holder killed five young people before taking her own life.
In the face of unimaginable loss, Ricky's father, Brian Suttles, made the decision to donate his children's organs, allowing them to give the gift of life even in death. He remembered both Ricky and Hanna as blessings on Earth who became blessings when they died. The tragedy left multiple families and the entire Pleasant Garden community in a state of shock and profound grief, struggling to understand the senseless violence that had taken so many young lives. As of November 2021, ten years after the tragedy, the deep scars remained in the close-knit community.