Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 6 sources
In the fall of 1983, Isabel Askew, an 85-year-old White woman, was living a quiet life in her apartment on West Bonita Avenue in Claremont, California. She shared the home with her daughter, Adrienne. Loved ones knew that Isabel had some difficulty with mobility, which made the events that followed all the more baffling and tragic for investigators and her family. Her life, and a chain of events that would haunt her family for decades, was irrevocably altered when she vanished from her home.

Around October of 1983, Isabel was reported missing from the apartment. For more than a week, her whereabouts remained a painful mystery. The search ended in a grim discovery when her partially nude body was found in a remote vineyard near Ontario International Airport, miles from her Claremont home. Police were immediately faced with troubling questions, chief among them how an elderly woman with trouble getting around could have ended up in such a distant location. Because her body had been exposed to the elements for a significant time, the coroner was unable to officially determine a cause of death due to the level of decomposition.

For three years, the circumstances surrounding Isabel's death remained an unsolved and deeply suspicious case. Then, in June 1986, tragedy struck the Askew family again in the most horrific and intimate way possible. Isabel’s daughter, 56-year-old Adrienne Askew, was found murdered inside the very same West Bonita Avenue apartment she had once shared with her mother. A retired school crossing guard, Adrienne had been sexually assaulted and strangled. She was discovered lying face-up in her bed, with bedding pulled over her head.

Detectives at the time looked for connections between the mother's and daughter's deaths, but the investigation grew cold and remained inconclusive for years. The cases became part of a terrifying chapter in Southern California history, as a serial predator known as the "Westside Rapist" had terrorized elderly women in the 1970s, and a new wave of similar crimes began in the Pomona Valley area, including Claremont, in the 1980s. The link between these cases would not become clear for more than two decades, when advances in DNA technology allowed a special cold-case unit to revisit the crimes.

In 2009, investigators announced a major breakthrough. DNA evidence linked a 72-year-old former state insurance claims adjuster named John Floyd Thomas Jr. to a string of murders. Thomas was arrested and charged with the murders of seven elderly women, committed between 1972 and 1986. One of the victims he was charged with raping and strangling was Adrienne Askew. In April 2011, to avoid a potential death sentence, Thomas pleaded guilty to all seven counts of murder and was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

While the conviction brought a measure of justice for Adrienne’s murder, it left the case of her mother, Isabel, in a painful state of limbo. At the time of Thomas’s arrest, detectives announced they were re-examining the evidence in Isabel's death, and he remains the primary suspect. During his sentencing, the prosecutor read a statement from Adrienne's granddaughter that spoke to the family's certainty. "Were these murders coincidental? Surely not," the statement read.

As of 2011, John Floyd Thomas Jr. had not been charged in the death of Isabel Askew. Her case is inextricably linked to one of Los Angeles’s most prolific serial killers, yet it officially remains unsolved. The question of what happened to the 85-year-old woman in the last days of her life, and how she came to be left in a lonely vineyard, is a mystery that endures.