Jay Hudson Bassett-Santiago was a baby boy with a smile that could sparkle. Born on March 10, 2012, in Providence, Rhode Island, eight-month-old Jay was remembered by his maternal grandmother, Shelly Medeiros, as "a love." He lived in Worcester, Massachusetts, with his parents, Hailey E. Bassett and Marben Santiago, and his sister, Giselle. His large, loving family included grandparents, a great-grandmother, numerous aunts, uncles, and cousins who adored him. An online tribute recalled him as a "beautiful, baby boy," with one person writing, "If I had artistic talent & were asked to paint a portrait of an angel, it would look like your darling boy."
The morning of Thanksgiving, November 22, 2012, took a tragic turn that would shatter his family. At approximately 7:47 a.m., first responders were dispatched to the family's home at 29 Richmond Avenue in Worcester for a report of a baby who was not breathing. Jay was rushed to a local hospital, unconscious.
He remained in the hospital for three days, but he never recovered. On November 25, 2012, surrounded by his family at UMASS Hospital, Jay passed away.
Initially, hospital staff suggested the cause of death might be Sudden Infant Death Syndrome. However, Jay's grandmother was troubled by a bruise she saw above his left eye in the emergency room. The family's suspicions and their push for answers led to a prolonged and painful wait for an official ruling from the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner. For a year and a half, Jay's grandmother persistently contacted the medical examiner's office, convinced that something was not right.
Finally, 18 months after his death, the official cause was determined. The updated death certificate ruled Jay's death a homicide, caused by "blunt force trauma to the head and neck, inflicted by others." This crucial ruling transformed the case into a criminal investigation, but the significant delay presented challenges. Police records indicated that Jay's parents were with him when he stopped breathing, but no charges have ever been filed in his death.
The investigation into the homicide of Jay Bassett-Santiago is being handled by the Worcester Police Department's Unresolved Homicide Unit. The case remains open and active, a source of ongoing pain for a family still seeking accountability. "The fact that it took so long changed the whole scenario," his grandmother told a reporter in 2015. "If it had been done when I wanted it done, somebody would be in jail right now. There's no doubt in my mind." In his obituary, his family shared a heart-wrenching sentiment: "His family will love him forever, like him for always, as long as their living, their baby he'll be."
As of 2026, Jay's death is still listed on the Worcester Police Department's roster of unsolved homicides. Investigators continue to seek information that could bring justice for the infant boy whose life was cut tragically short. Anyone with information about the death of Jay Bassett is urged to contact the Unresolved Homicide Unit at 508-799-8688. Anonymous tips can also be sent by texting 274637 with the message "TIPWPD" followed by the information, or via an anonymous web-based message through the Worcester Police Department's website.