Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 5 sources
In the final weeks of 2014, Ashley Mylette was a young woman navigating a difficult path. The 20-year-old female had spent much of her childhood with her grandparents in Holbrook, Massachusetts, while also moving between her separated parents' homes. In the months leading up to her death, she was reportedly living on the streets, grappling with addiction. Her family last saw her about four weeks before she was found. Her grandfather, Mark Mylette, would later speak of the "anger, the depression" that her unsolved murder brought upon his family, a horrible feeling he struggled to explain.

On December 28, 2014, a man walking his dog through a wooded area behind 251 North Quincy Street in Brockton, Massachusetts, made a horrifying discovery. He found the partially buried body of Ashley Mylette. Beneath her, investigators uncovered the skeletal remains of a second woman, later identified as 50-year-old Linda Schufeldt, who had been missing for nearly six months. Ashley's body was found dismembered, a brutal detail that prevented her family from having a proper viewing for a week. The area, near a local VFW post, was known to be used as an illegal dumping ground.

The investigation into the double homicide is managed by the Massachusetts State Police detectives assigned to the Plymouth County District Attorney's Office and the Brockton Police. The case took a significant turn when DNA evidence recovered from the crime scene provided a forensic link to a series of other violent crimes. The same unidentified male DNA profile was connected to three separate violent rapes that occurred in Brockton in October 2013, November 2013, and January 2014. Authorities believe the perpetrator targeted vulnerable women who struggled with addiction and were involved in prostitution. The FBI now considers the suspect a serial killer.

In March 2017, investigators publicly released a composite sketch of the person of interest, but it was not an image drawn from an eyewitness account. The Plymouth County District Attorney's office had partnered with Parabon NanoLabs, a Virginia-based company, to use the suspect's DNA to predict his physical appearance. This process, known as DNA phenotyping, generated a computer image predicting the man's eye color, hair color, and skin color. In 2018, the district attorney's office contracted with Parabon again to build a genealogical profile from the DNA in an attempt to identify relatives of the suspect through public genealogy websites, but this has not yet led to a breakthrough.

Over the years, family members and investigators have continued to appeal for information. "We never forget a victim, no matter how much time goes by," Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy J. Cruz stated. "We believe there are people that may have information about these crimes and I encourage them to come forward and share what they know." In 2019, the arrest of a man named Louis Coleman III for another murder prompted Ashley's grandfather to attend a court hearing, struck by a resemblance to the DNA-generated sketch, but no definitive link was announced.

In May 2024, a woman identified only as "Essi" came forward, believing she survived an attack by the same man in November 2013, just weeks before the bodies were found. She described being picked up by a handsome, clean-cut man in a black sedan, who then drove her to a remote area where he violently raped and strangled her for hours. She said she escaped only after telling him a friend was tracking the license plates of cars she entered. He reportedly told her, "he's killed girls."

As of April 2023, the murders of Ashley Mylette and Linda Schufeldt remain unsolved. The joint investigation by the Massachusetts State Police and Brockton Police is still active and ongoing. Authorities continue to seek tips from the public that could finally identify the man responsible for at least two murders and three rapes. Anyone with information regarding these cases is urged to contact the State Police Tip Line at the Plymouth County District Attorney's Office at 508-894-2584.