On a Thursday afternoon in the fall of 1987, a mother made a devastating discovery that would haunt her family and her community for decades. On October 15, 1987, Donald William Pence, a 61-year-old man, was found dead inside his Puyallup, Washington, home. It was his own mother who found him in his living room, the victim of a fatal gunshot wound. The violent end to his life marked the beginning of a complex and frustrating cold case that continues to puzzle investigators.
The crime occurred in what was then a smaller, more tight-knit community, making the brutal homicide particularly jarring. Puyallup, a city in Pierce County known for its annual fair and daffodil festival, was not accustomed to such violence. The murder of Donald Pence left a lasting scar and raised questions that have yet to be answered. Who would have targeted the 61-year-old, and why?
The lack of forced entry into his home suggested to some that he may have known his killer, but without witnesses or a clear motive, the investigation stalled early on.
The Puyallup Police Department launched an immediate and thorough investigation into the homicide. Detectives canvassed the neighborhood, interviewed friends, family, and associates, and processed the crime scene for any shred of evidence that could lead them to the person responsible. Despite their efforts, the trail grew cold. No suspects were publicly named, and no arrests were ever made in connection with the murder. The case, officially designated as Case 87005045, was eventually moved to the department's cold case files, a collection of unsolved crimes waiting for a new lead, a new witness, or a technological breakthrough.
Over the years, the file on Donald Pence’s murder has been periodically reviewed. Advances in forensic science, particularly in DNA analysis, have offered hope for solving many older cases. However, it remains unknown if any testable evidence was preserved from the original crime scene that could be utilized with modern techniques. For the family of Donald Pence, the passage of time has not eased the pain of their loss or the gnawing uncertainty surrounding his death. The memory of finding her son murdered is a burden his mother carried for the rest of her life.
The Puyallup Police Department continues to list the murder of Donald William Pence as an active cold case. Investigators believe that even after more than three decades, someone in the community may hold the key to unlocking the truth. Alliances change, and individuals who may have been afraid to speak in 1987 may now be in a position to come forward. The department encourages anyone with knowledge of the case, no matter how insignificant it may seem, to contact their Criminal Investigations Division.
The case remains a quiet but persistent mystery in the city's history. While other local cold cases have received more media attention over the years, the search for justice for Donald Pence has never been officially abandoned. His is one of several unsolved homicides and disappearances from that era in Puyallup that law enforcement hopes to one day close, bringing a measure of peace to the families who have waited so long for answers. Anyone with information is urged to contact the Puyallup Police Department.