Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 5 sources
In 1972, Gary Hinkley entered the foster care system in Washington, first living in a home in Edmonds. A few years later, the 17-year-old boy was placed with another foster family in a quiet residential neighborhood in Lynnwood. He was the son of Louis and Elizabeth Hinkley and had five siblings. For reasons that remain part of his private history, he was living apart from his family, navigating his teenage years in a home that was not his own when his life was violently cut short.

In the pre-dawn hours of January 29, 1975, a fire tore through the house in the 3400 block of 177th Place SW. The blaze, which began around 4:45 a.m., quickly engulfed the structure. Two other children living in the foster home managed to escape the flames and the suffocating smoke, but Gary was trapped inside. Firefighters who responded to the scene pulled the teenager from the burning building, but his injuries were catastrophic. The heat and flames had been merciless, leaving burns across an estimated 85 percent of his body. According to a detective who later reviewed the case, only a small patch of skin on his chest was left unharmed.

Gary was rushed to a hospital, where he began an agonizing fight for his life. For more than a month, he clung to survival, enduring unimaginable pain from his injuries. His battle ended on March 4, 1975, when he finally succumbed. By then, fire investigators had thoroughly examined the scene of the blaze and had come to a grim conclusion: the fire was no accident. It had been deliberately set, transforming a tragic house fire into a homicide investigation. Gary Hinkley had been murdered.

The Snohomish County Sheriff's Office took charge of the case, but the investigation quickly ran into difficulties. There were no immediate suspects, and a clear motive for the arson attack never materialized. Detectives were left with a series of unanswered questions that have persisted for decades. Who would target a home with children inside, and why was Gary the one who could not escape? Investigators have long been interested in hearing from anyone who might have information about other suspicious fires that occurred in the Lynnwood area around that same time, hoping a pattern might reveal a clue.

Years turned into decades, and Gary's case grew cold, becoming one of Snohomish County's oldest unsolved homicides. In an effort to breathe new life into the investigation, detectives included Gary’s story in the state’s first deck of cold-case playing cards, which were distributed in Washington's jails and prisons. Gary’s face and the details of his death were featured on the six of hearts, with the hope that an inmate with knowledge of the crime might come forward in exchange for a reward. A 2009 report noted that investigators had been unable to locate Gary’s parents to let them know they were still pursuing justice for their son. Sadly, public records show his father, Louis, and his mother, Elizabeth, both passed away without ever seeing his killer identified.

As of October 2025, the murder of Gary Hinkley remains unsolved. No suspect has ever been named, and the reason for the senseless act of arson that claimed his life is still a mystery. The questions linger like smoke, refusing to clear after nearly half a century. The Snohomish County Sheriff’s Office continues to seek information that could finally provide answers and a measure of justice for the boy who endured an agonizing death.