Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 2 sources
In the winter of 1973, the Boston neighborhoods of Mattapan and Hyde Park lost a man described as the very embodiment of community spirit. Joseph D. Hershenson, a 34-year-old local businessman, was known for his deep commitment to the area he called home. His efforts to improve the community were not just a pastime but a passion, and he was recognized by city leaders as a man of civic pride and humanitarianism. He was an active and innovative member of many local organizations, including the Board of Trade, and was remembered for dedicating countless hours to the betterment of his community.

The promise of his continued contributions was cut short on the evening of Thursday, February 1, 1973. On that night, officers from the Boston Police Department were called to respond to a shooting at 1284 Blue Hill Avenue in the Mattapan neighborhood. Inside the commercial building, they discovered Joseph Hershenson. He had been shot, and first responders pronounced him deceased at the scene. The city that he had worked so tirelessly to improve had become the scene of his tragic and untimely death.

The case was immediately opened as a homicide investigation by the Boston Police Department. Following an autopsy, the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner officially confirmed the cause of death was a gunshot wound and ruled the manner of death a homicide. In the days and weeks that followed, detectives began the difficult work of piecing together the final hours of Joseph’s life and searching for the person or persons responsible for taking it.

The shocking and violent nature of the crime sent ripples of grief through the community and reached the highest levels of city government. Shortly after his death, the Boston City Council passed a formal resolution to mourn what they called the "shocking and tragic death of Joseph D. Hershenson." The council's official proceedings honored him as a "devoted community leader and businessman of Mattapan" who worked tirelessly for the area. This public tribute underscored the profound sense of loss felt by those who knew him and had witnessed his dedication firsthand.

Despite the initial investigation and the high regard in which Joseph was held, his murder yielded no arrests. Over the subsequent decades, the case grew cold. Details about the investigation, including any potential motives or persons of interest, have never been publicly released by law enforcement. No witnesses have come forward publicly, and no definitive evidence has been announced that could lead to a breakthrough in the case.

More than fifty years later, the murder of Joseph D. Hershenson remains an unsolved homicide, listed on the official cold case files of the Boston Police Department. The questions of who targeted the beloved community leader and why have lingered without answers, leaving a painful void for those who remember his work and his presence. The case is a stark reminder of a life of service ended by a senseless act of violence. The Boston Police Department continues to seek information that might finally bring justice for Joseph Hershenson and his community.

Links to Additional Sources (2)

See any mistakes? Let us know!