In the spring of 1973, a decade marked by profound social change and turmoil in Boston, 78-year-old Charles Shumrak was living a quiet life in the city's Mattapan neighborhood. The world knew him by his name and age, but the details of his life—the stories he told, the people he loved, the daily routines that defined his nearly eight decades—have been largely lost to time, overshadowed by the brutal circumstances of his death. He was a man, a member of a community, whose life story was violently and permanently interrupted, leaving behind a silence that has now lasted for more than half a century.
On Wednesday, March 14, 1973, officers from the Boston Police Department were dispatched to a residence at 27 Fessenden Street in Mattapan. The call was for a report of head trauma. Inside the home, they found Charles Shumrak. He was pronounced deceased at the scene.
The subsequent investigation by the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner was definitive: Charles had not died of natural causes or by accident. The manner of his death was officially ruled a homicide, the result of a violent and intentional act. He became one of dozens of homicide victims in Boston that year whose cases would grow cold, their files gathering dust as the city moved on to new tragedies.
The investigation into the murder of Charles Shumrak began as all do, with detectives canvassing the neighborhood, seeking witnesses, and processing the crime scene for evidence. But the trail quickly faded. In an era before widespread DNA technology and digital records, homicide investigations relied heavily on immediate tips and witness cooperation. For reasons that remain locked in the unwritten history of the case, no arrests were ever made. The case is now in the hands of the Boston Police Department's Unsolved Homicide Unit, a dedicated group of investigators who periodically review the city's oldest and most difficult cases, hoping a new technology, a fresh look at old evidence, or a person's long-overdue crisis of conscience might finally provide a breakthrough.
The Boston of 1973 was a city grappling with tension. The early seventies were a period of economic strain and social unrest, and violent crime was a significant concern for residents. That year alone, the Boston Police Department recorded numerous homicides that remain unsolved to this day. Each name on that list represents a story cut short and a family left without answers. Charles Shumrak's case is one of many from that time, a stark reminder of a violent period in the city's history. His murder occurred in Mattapan, a neighborhood undergoing significant demographic shifts, adding another layer of complexity to the social fabric of the time.
Decades have passed since Charles Shumrak was killed in his home. The original detectives assigned to his case have long since retired or passed away themselves. Neighbors who may have seen or heard something have likely moved on or are no longer alive. The home at 27 Fessenden Street still stands, a silent witness to a crime that has gone unpunished for generations. Without family members coming forward publicly or renewed media interest, the memory of Charles himself has faded, leaving only the stark, official record of his violent death.
The case of Charles Shumrak remains an open and active investigation on the books of the Boston Police Department. The fundamental questions of who would have targeted an elderly man and why remain unanswered. As of November 2026, his killer has never been identified. The Boston Police Department continues to seek information on all of its cold cases, emphasizing that no piece of information is too small or insignificant. Detectives believe that someone, somewhere, may still hold the key to unlocking this decades-old mystery and bringing a measure of justice to Charles Shumrak. Anyone with information is urged to contact the Boston Police Department Homicide Unit or to remain anonymous by calling the CrimeStoppers Tip Line at 1-800-494-TIPS.