Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 3 sources
In the early 1970s, Boston’s Bay Village was a haven for the city’s gay community, a place of relative acceptance with bars that offered sanctuary and belonging. One such place was the Other Side bar, a popular institution where people could connect, away from the often harsh judgment of the outside world. It was in this environment of presumed safety that a night out for two young men turned into a descent into unimaginable terror, leaving one of them dead in a crime that has remained unsolved for over five decades.

On the night of Friday, July 13, 1973, Jeremiah “Jerry” Lynch, a 21-year-old man, was with his friend, 22-year-old Steven Tuscher, at the Other Side. As they left the bar, they accepted a ride from a group of six men who promised them a good time with drinks and marijuana. The two friends got into the car, likely unaware that they were being driven into a trap. The journey that followed was not a joyride, but a terrifying ordeal. The driver took them on a rambling, circuitous route through the city, while the men in the car began to verbally and sexually harass Jeremiah.

The ride of terror ended near the South Street Gate of the Arnold Arboretum, a sprawling botanical park in the Jamaica Plain and Roslindale neighborhoods. There, Jeremiah and Steven were forced out of the vehicle and subjected to a savage attack. The six assailants beat them with their fists, rocks, and improvised weapons. One of the men tried to stab Steven in the eye with a broken car antenna. As the brutal assault continued, Steven begged the attackers to "leave Jerry alone." They did not. Both men were stabbed repeatedly before their assailants rolled their battered bodies into an open sewer. Steven Tuscher, despite his severe injuries, managed to crawl out of the muck five hours later and find help. Jeremiah Lynch, a young male whose life was just beginning, was not as fortunate; he drowned in the filth at the bottom of the sewer.

The Boston Police Department investigated the horrific crime. Steven Tuscher, the lone survivor, was able to provide descriptions of his attackers. The investigation led to the arrest of two suspects just days later: 19-year-old Keith Christie and 23-year-old Robert Ray. Tuscher identified both men in a police lineup, and it seemed as though justice for Jeremiah was within reach. The search for the other four assailants continued, but the case against the two men in custody soon fell apart in a deeply troubling manner.

By September 1973, both Christie and Ray were released, reportedly at the suggestion of the police themselves. The rationale given was that the surviving victim, Steven Tuscher, was "no longer a credible witness." In the aftermath of the traumatic attack, Tuscher had been hospitalized following a suicide attempt. He had reportedly spoken to the press about his hope that shock treatments would erase the horrific memories of that night. With the key witness deemed unreliable, the case against the primary suspects dissolved, and the investigation into Jeremiah Lynch’s murder stalled.

The murder of Jeremiah Lynch was one of several violent, and often fatal, attacks against gay men in Boston during that era, creating a climate of fear within the community. These crimes were frequently characterized by extreme brutality and were often met with a frustrating lack of resolution. Over the years, the world has changed, but the pain of this unsolved case lingers.

As of 2024, the murder of Jeremiah Lynch officially remains on the Boston Police Department's list of unsolved homicides from 1973. The names of the other four men who participated in the deadly assault were never made public, and they have never been brought to justice. For more than 50 years, the question of who was fully responsible for the brutal end of a young man's life in a Boston park has gone unanswered.