Justin Jonathan Robert
POLLARI
38
14
69 inches
69 inches
150 lbs
150 lbs
White / Caucasian
Male
On a cold December evening in 2001, 14-year-old Justin Jonathan Robert Pollari disappeared from the small community of Hilton Beach on St. Joseph Island, Ontario. The last confirmed day anyone saw him was December 7, 2001. In the immediate aftermath, the official account was that Justin, a boy with blond hair, blue eyes, and a dimple in his chin, had a disagreement with his family, grabbed his prized skateboard and a backpack, and left his home. He was reportedly seen with a cut on his lip. For years, his case was officially classified by the Ontario Provincial Police as a runaway, with searches and attention focused on the possibility that he had traveled to Toronto. This narrative was bolstered by a tip that emerged four years later from a gas station attendant in Sault Ste. Marie, who recalled seeing a young man resembling Justin getting into a transport truck. His family searched in Toronto, but found no trace of him. For more than two decades, this remained the prevailing story, though it was one his biological mother, Lori Smith, never believed, stating that her son was not a troubled teen and would not have run away. In recent years, a renewed investigation by a private investigator has brought a vastly different and more complex picture to light, largely dismissing the runaway theory. More than 60 witnesses have come forward, many of whom were friends with Justin at the time and claim their accounts were initially dismissed by law enforcement. A more detailed timeline of Justin's final hours has been constructed, indicating he spent time at a local restaurant and a friend's camp before attending a dance at the Hilton Beach Community Hall. It was there, according to multiple witnesses, that his father allegedly entered and forcibly removed him from the venue. Later, Justin apparently returned to the hall and was eventually driven home by two friends, who may have been the last to see him. The renewed investigation has uncovered several disturbing circumstances that were allegedly overlooked in the initial inquiry. Friends reported that the dirt floor in the basement of the home where Justin was living was cemented over in the weeks following his disappearance, a tip they claim was ignored by police at the time. Furthermore, new witness testimony from a former teacher and a childhood friend suggests a pattern of abuse in the home, challenging the narrative of a teen who simply left after an argument. Tips have also identified specific locations on St. Joseph Island where Justin's remains could potentially be, including beneath a garage that was under construction when he vanished and a property formerly used by his father to store equipment. The case of Justin Pollari remains an open investigation, now centered not on the idea of a runaway, but on a collection of eyewitness accounts and evidence that suggest a far more tragic conclusion to the night he disappeared. The focus has shifted from searching for a boy who left to uncovering what happened to a boy who, by many accounts, never had the chance to.
Hat Black, Toque Jewelry wears heavy chains Jewelry Wood, Nametag with the inscription of "Woody" Luggage Black, Back pack Shirt Black, Size medium hooded sweatshirt Shoes Red, Running Deformity Chin, dimple Pierce Left Ear, two earrings
Dec 07, 2001
Hilton Beach
Ontario
East Algoma OPP OPP ONCMPUR ; 1-705-330-4144;
Ontario
1-877-934-6363
1-877-934-6363
Law Enforcement
RM01176313
East Algoma OPP OPP ONCMPUR ; 1-705-330-4144;
Blonde
Blue
Blue
Build: Medium; Complexion: Ruddy; Hair details: Sometimes worn in a "Mohawk" style
No
Read full forum posts and contribute to this case discussion.
Unlock forum access — $3.97/month
