Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 6 sources
Albert Plummer, a 48-year-old man from Andover, Massachusetts, was a victim of mistaken identity in a brutal mob hit that was not meant for him. His death on March 20, 1973, left a lasting scar, a story of being in the wrong place at the most tragically wrong time, caught in the crossfire of Boston’s violent underworld.

On the night of March 19, 1973, Plummer was driving a car on Commercial Street in Boston's historic North End. With him were two passengers, Frank Capizzi, then 38, and Hugh "Sonny" Shields, 36, of Dorchester. As they drove near number 447, the night exploded in a hail of gunfire. It was a carefully planned ambush, a scene one survivor would later describe as being hit by a "firing squad." For more than two minutes, a relentless barrage of approximately 100 bullets slammed into the vehicle, causing it to implode. When the shooting stopped, Albert Plummer was dead. Capizzi and Shields were both critically wounded.

The investigation by the Boston Police Department soon revealed the horrifying truth behind the attack. The ambush was the work of the notorious Winter Hill Gang, and the intended target was not Plummer. Instead, the hitmen were hunting for a rival gang leader, Alfred "Indian Al" Notarangeli. Winter Hill Gang hitman John Martorano would later testify that he and other gang members, including the infamous James "Whitey" Bulger, had been enlisted by the New England Mafia to kill Notarangeli. They had received a tip that Notarangeli was at a waterfront restaurant and believed they were following his car when they unleashed the deadly assault on Plummer's vehicle.

Frank Capizzi, who survived with around 30 wounds from bullets, glass, and metal, testified decades later at Bulger's trial. He recalled the terror of the attack, which he said felt like it lasted "a day and a half." One slug came to rest just millimeters from his heart. Fearing for his life and the safety of his family, Capizzi left Boston soon after the shooting. He described his family as "living in the throat of the dragon for 40 years."

Years later, the Plummer murder became one of the many crimes detailed in a massive federal racketeering indictment against James "Whitey" Bulger. Bulger was charged with participating in 19 murders, including Plummer's. During his 2013 trial, prosecutors presented evidence and testimony outlining the mistaken-identity killing. Martorano testified that he and another gangster, Howie Winter, were the triggermen, while Bulger and others were in a separate "radio car," using walkie-talkies to coordinate the hit. Despite the testimony, the jury did not return a guilty verdict on the specific count of Albert Plummer's murder.

The case remains officially unsolved. As of August 2013, with the conclusion of Bulger's trial, no one has been convicted for the murder of Albert Plummer. The Boston Police Department continues to list his death on its official page of 1973 unsolved homicides. For Plummer, an innocent man from Andover, a drive through the North End one spring night ended in a violent death that was a footnote in a bloody gang war, a casualty of a bullet that had someone else's name on it.